Monday, October 8, 2007

Surveillance violates privacy, ACLU says

Are Americans trading in the Bill of Rights for a bill of goods? In examining the actions being taken in city after city, the apparent answer is yes. You don't have to look too hard or travel very far to find a surveillance camera near you. The Contra Costa Times reports on our emerging surveillance society, one largely accepted, and even supported by the public, all in the name of "keeping us safe".

An ACLU study on the proliferation of video surveillance systems in California is cited in the aticle, as is recent evidence coming out of London - which has 10,000 crime-fighting CCTV cameras (at the cost of £200 million) - casting doubt on their ability to help solve crimes. In fact:

"A comparison of the number of cameras in each London borough with the proportion of crimes solved there found that police are no more likely to catch offenders in areas with hundreds of cameras than in those with hardly any."

More from the Contra Costa Times piece:

Cities and counties, taking a cue -- and billions of dollars -- from the federal government, are buying into the idea that more surveillance translates into safer communities and a more secure nation, the group said.

And it's happening under the noses of a largely acquiescent public, said Barbara Zerbe Macnab, chairwoman of the ACLU's Berkeley-Albany-Richmond-Kensington chapter.

"There is no public outrage," she said. "That's what frightens me most."

...

The panelists also warned that untold numbers of private surveillance cameras, such as those in stores, shopping mall parking lots and office building lobbies, complement the public agency-owned cameras because companies routinely make recordings available to police.

...

Ozer said security cameras can make immediate suspects out of people engaged in innocent acts such as sitting on a stoop chatting with friends on a hot summer night, driving around the block in business districts looking for a parking space, picking up a spouse from work or taking a photo of a tall building as a tourism memento.

At some point we're going to really need, as a society, to reflect on just what personal privacy entails, how it fits into our concept of the constitution, and whether giving up this privacy is really outweighed by the proclaimed security benefits these cameras provide? At this point, the answer is clear...we are giving up a whole lot of what it means to live in a free country for a "security mirage" supplied by Big Brother.

Against a national ID

The Los Angeles Times correctly editorializes in opposition to a National ID card - in particular the idea that one should have to provide such a card to vote. The last thing our country needs is a modernized "poll tax".

The editorial reads:

If anything, advancements in electronic data storage argue against an all-purpose Social Security or other identification card because an identity thief would need to steal only one document to gain access to a universe of personal information. That is why both federal and state agencies discourage -- and, in the case of California, forbid -- businesses from displaying Social Security numbers on documents, badges or correspondence unless required by law.But in trying to arrest the drift toward an intrusive ID-card society, privacy advocates must choose their battles carefully. One worth fighting is over photo ID requirements for voters.

Constitutional or not, they are too sweeping a solution to too small a problem. In the absence of evidence of significant fraud at polling places, a photo ID requirement is at best a distraction and at worse an obstacle to the exercise of the franchise.

...

This page has supported proposals in California to issue driver's licenses to illegal immigrants, provided that they submit a birth certificate, an ID from their country of origin and proof of California residency, and undergo a background check. But under the Real ID Act, such licenses wouldn't pass muster for federal purposes. As a result, travelers from a state that issued licenses to illegal immigrants might have to carry a passport even for domestic travel, bringing a national ID card that much closer to reality.

Read the entire editorial here...

Friday, October 5, 2007

A world under surveillance

While yesterday's column by Robert Ellis Smith took a more optimistic view of the people's ability to prevent a full fledged "surveillaince society", this article by Stephanie Stein in The Suburban paints a more ominous privacy future. As privacy experts quoted in the article point out, the rise of surveillance technologies, particularly RFID's - on a global scale - should give serious concern to all of us that cherish our privacy...and liberty.

Thankfully in California, we have Senator Simitian leading the charge for common sense regulation of RFID technology, but in other parts of the country, and world, such action is not being seen, and in fact, are going the opposite direction.

Stein writes:

From surveillance cameras to data pirating, every bit of life is scanned and stored to meet economic and political agendas. Until awareness is heightened and proper legislation put in place, our right to privacy will continue to be violated, said privacy activists at the Privacy Rights in a World under Surveillance conference held last weekend at Montreal’s Sheraton Centre.

...

RFID is the modern model of the espionage tool first used in the Soviet Union in 1946. Today, the RFID chip can be inserted into passports, vehicles, animals, even into inventory systems. With global tracking boxes built into cars, and workplace monitoring devices that record everything you do, data mining is here to stay. Some experts believe the human microchip is not far behind.

...

From reader technologies that track our habits, to the surveillance of movement and profiling of passengers through Passenger Name Records (PNR) and entry-exit schemes, our right to privacy is on the verge of becoming obsolete.

...

Maureen Webb from The International Civil Liberties Monitoring Group (ICLMG) said since 9/11, the U.S. is demanding an integrated security environment where the population is biometrically registered, tracked and monitored. “Citizens’ information is stored for 100 years, and shared by agencies, without warrants, treating the entire population as suspects.”

Thursday, October 4, 2007

Reviving Privacy - Commentary

This column in Forbes Magazine by Robert Ellis Smith, a lawyer and author, and publisher of the Privacy Journal newsletter, is a must read! Is there a public revival in interest in the issue of privacy? And as this blog is especially interested in determining and articulating - where does that intersection lie between security, technology and privacy? Similarly, to what degree do corporations have the right to compile, share, and sell our personal information?

Fortunately, this editorial goes far in answering, or at least coming close to, a lot of these questions. This is not to say however, we quite share his level of optimism in terms of the public's recognition of the importance of this issue. While there has been an opinion shift among Americans on it, the question remains whether this will lead to a more active and energized public that is ready to fight for their right to privacy.

Mr. Smith writes:

Is there a revival of interest among Americans in protecting personal privacy? I believe that there is, and you can see the signs everywhere. This comes at a time when the President has nominated for attorney general a judge who seems to think that civil liberties protections can be ignored in difficult times, when we are rushing towards a de facto national ID card required of all Americans, and when the Bush administration continues to assert unprecedented claims to conduct secret collections of personal information and to monitor electronic communications with total disregard for existing laws.

...

Since 2001, there has been a maturing of our attitudes towards combating terrorism and protecting civil liberties. Many Americans now realize, for instance, that a mandatory national ID card is not going to help at all secure airplanes (from non-resident shoe bombers?). They understand that our pre-existing surveillance laws have always allowed for emergency and wartime procedures.

They know that allowing lots of entities to collect Social Security numbers only diminishes our individual security and does not enhance our national security. They have manifested a belief that by strengthening individual privacy and autonomy we might just embolden citizens to participate in the "war against terror" by staying alert to suspicious activities.

...

In the fall of 2001, 70% of Americans said they favored a mandatory national ID card. Just a few months later, support had ebbed to 26%, and in later years polls have shown that most Americans aren't so sure that a national ID is a good idea at all. In 2005, Congress went along with one member who insisted on a law increasing the documentation for a driver's license and requiring that all state licenses be uniform. In 2007, several states expressed opposition to the so-called REAL ID requirement, and 25% of respondents in a Zogby Interactive Survey said they disliked the idea.

...

This revival of concern has put pressure on Google to reconsider its headlong charge towards increasingly intrusive search services without adequate privacy safeguards. Another sign of the revival: Corporate representatives are attending conferences on privacy in record numbers.

Please read this optimistic call to action on privacy and individual liberty at a time when each are under outright assault from both government and big business.

Wednesday, October 3, 2007

Former Bush Attorney: Parts of Wiretapping Program "Illegal"

Let us hope that every elected representative will reflect on this testimony when they re-consider authorizing FISA in its recently "disabled" form. This from the Center from American Progress on yesterday's incredible testimony by a former Bush Attorney:

Jack Goldsmith, a former Bush administration attorney, told Congress yesterday that President Bush's warrantless wiretapping program was "the biggest legal mess [he] had ever encountered" and after leading an internal review, he "could not find a legal basis for some aspects of the program." Contradicting testimony by former Attorney General Alberto Gonzales, who said there were no "serious disagreements about the program" within the administration, Goldsmith stated, "There were enormous disagreements," with the internal fight culminating "in a threat by Goldsmith, [former Deputy Attorney General James] Comey, and others to resign en masse if the program were allowed to continue without changes." Goldsmith added that Vice President Cheney's counsel David Addington had "told him that his position might mean failure to halt a new terrorist attack that would leave him with the blood of thousands on his hands." Goldsmith's testimony also emphasized the reluctance of the White House to allow any oversight of its wiretapping program.

And let's not forget the telecommunication industry's unquestioning and obedient complicity in the illegal program. This from the Associated Press:

The FISA court is meant to balance the government's need to periodically collect intelligence inside the United States and the U.S. public's right to privacy. Secret FISA court orders can compel telecommunications companies to cooperate with government surveillance requests and indemnify them from lawsuits.

The Bush administration has asked Congress to grant retroactive immunity to telecommunications companies that cooperated. Around 40 lawsuits related to the surveillance are pending in federal courts. The administration has refused to give Congress details on the companies' involvement.

On Tuesday, the House Energy and Commerce Committee went to the companies themselves, asking AT&T, Verizon and Qwest for details on the government's secret surveillance program. Of the three, reportedly only Qwest rebuffed the government, insisting on a FISA court order first.The law prohibits telecommunications companies from sharing customer records without a court order.

The committee asked in letters sent Tuesday whether the companies allowed government agencies to install equipment on telecommunications lines to copy private Internet traffic, whether they have provided information on customers' networks of associates to the FBI, and whether they have ever been offered legal indemnity or compensation for cooperating with surveillance requests.

Tuesday, October 2, 2007

Retailers lobbying hard against AB 779

AB 779 - Jones' data protection bill - continues to get a lot of press coverage. To no ones surprise, the LA Times reported today that there is some heavy lobbying of the Governor going on by the retail industry.

The bill would help reduce incidences of identity theft by requiring businesses to take steps to safeguard consumer financial information, including encrypting computer records to avoid hacking, disposal of these records promptly and safely, and would prohibit businesses from storing customer credit card or debit card pin numbers and security codes. This year, the parent company that owns TJ Maxx and Marshalls stores acknowledged that 45 million credit card and debit card records were hacked from inadequately secured store computers by ID thieves sitting in parking lots outside stores.

Marc Lifsher reports:

"Going to the mall simply should not be identity theft Russian roulette," said the bill's author, Assemblyman Dave Jones (D-Sacramento). "What's happening is that retailers are keeping the credit and debit card information, and it is available to hackers and other identity thieves, who perpetrate fraud." He said that only about 40% of retailers and other organizations that accept credit card payments were complying with security guidelines developed by major credit card companies.

...

Credit unions support the bill, but most large business trade groups are asking the governor for a veto. Jeanne Cain, a lobbyist with the California Chamber of Commerce, said the bill would make retailers potentially liable in lawsuits even if they fully complied with its security conditions.

Frank Russo of the California Progress Report points out the fact that though the bill was overwhelmingly approved by the California Legislature, its fate is still uncertain:

It received its final passage in the Assembly 73-0 in September with 47 of 48 Democrats in support and 26 of 32 Republicans voting for it. Before its final amendments it had previously passed the Assembly in June on a 58-2 vote. It passed the California State Senate on a 30 to 6 vote with the support of 22 of 25 Democrats and 8 of those often difficult 15 Republican Senators.

Its author, Assemblymember Dave Jones, worked with a number of groups to make sure that it was a workable law, and the bill won the support of an impressive array of those from consumer, business, and law enforcement fighting identity theft and the abuses of the retail industry that does not comply with contracts they have made with credit card companies. Sponsored by the California Credit Union League, it is supported by Consumers Union, the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s office, Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department, the Consumer Federation of California, Privacy Rights Clearinghouse, the California State Employees Association, AFSCME – American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, the California Public Interest Group (CalPIRG), and the Sacramento County Sheriff’s Department, to name a few. The LA Times, San Francisco Chronicle, and Riverside Press Enterprise editorialized in support of the bill, recognizing its importance.

Yet its fate is uncertain because of a massive behind the scenes lobbying effort by the California Retailers Association and the California Chamber of Commerce.

...

A number of bad apples amongst California's retailers have a shoddy, shocking record of performance here--one that cannot withstand the light of day. Here is what Jones told the Governor in his letter asking for a signature so that this bill can become law:

"According to recent information published by Visa, which helped write the data security standards, only 40% of our largest retailers are following the PCI standards, despite the fact that they are currently contractually obligated to do so. As a result consumers are put at risk of data breaches, credit and debit card fraud, and ID theft. And financial institutions also bear the substantial costs of notifying consumers and reissuing compromised credit and debit cards, all because common-sense rules aren’t being followed by retail establishments. The best data breach is one that never happens – AB 779 will prevent data breaches, pure and simple."

Judge Rules Provisions in Patriot Act to Be Illegal

Some good news on the privacy front for a change! The New York Times covers the recent landmark decision by a federal district court judge in Oregon.

A federal judge in Oregon ruled Wednesday that crucial parts of the USA Patriot Act were not constitutional because they allowed federal surveillance and searches of Americans without demonstrating probable cause.

...

“For over 200 years, this nation has adhered to the rule of law — with unparalleled success,” Judge Aiken’s opinion said in finding violations of the Fourth Amendment prohibitions against unreasonable search and seizure. “A shift to a nation based on extraconstitutional authority is prohibited, as well as ill advised.”

...

In examining the history of the Federal Intelligence Surveillance Act, the opinion discussed a change by Congress in October 2001, under the Patriot Act, that allows surveillance and searches if the government declares that “a significant purpose” of that activity is gathering foreign intelligence. In the past, such searches and surveillance had been allowed if “the purpose” was to obtain foreign intelligence.

Congress’s intent, the opinion said, was “to break down barriers between criminal law enforcement and intelligence gathering.” Judge Aiken said a practical effect of “a seemingly minor change in wording” was to allow the government to avoid the constitutional probable cause requirement.