Friday, October 19, 2007

The Ultimate Cyberthief Gift: CA's Veto

As I mentioned here a few days back when discussing the fate of the four privacy protection bills that made it to the Governor's desk, AB 779 was the most important from a consumer perspective. Unfortunately, due to heavy lobbying by the retail industry, the Governor vetoed what was an overwhelmigly popular bill.

To better understand the possible ramifications of this veto, and the gift that the Governor has given identity thieves, check out this article by Evan Schuman, eWEEK.com's retail technology editor.

Evan writes:

Wondering what to get that cyberthief on your list who seems to have already taken everything? California's data breach bill veto is just the thing and it's in time for the holidays.

...

The nation's most populated state—which had already been the leader of data breach notification laws—was the best shot of keeping the movement alive. In other words, if this could be made into law anywhere, it would be California. But a lot more was at stake than merely getting a second state to fall in. California's proposed law specified that California residents would be covered.

This is as opposed to merely saying that it only impacted stores in California.By making the law cover the 37 million residents of California (remember that the total U.S. population is barely 300 million), it posed a legal challenge for retailers.

...

Is the bill necessarily dead? Not quite. The bill had sailed through both the California legislature and the senate with overwhelming percentages, more than enough to over-ride the governor's veto. But political realities in California make that unlikely but not impossible.

...

...the bill couldn't re-emerge in any form until Jan. 7, which likely means a decision no sooner than November.In the meantime, though, data thieves can rest easy and celebrate. They might even buy a round or two for the celebrating retail lobbyists at the other end of the bar. They finally have something they can agree on: mandatory security rules are a bad thing.

Click here to read the article in its entirety...

Thursday, October 18, 2007

Dodd Stops Domestic Spying Bill!

For more information on the issue see the prior blog post from earlier today. Suffice it to say, I need to update what just a few minutes ago was another defeat for privacy and the constitution. Just as Democrats in the Senate were going to capitulate to the Bush administration on the issue of giving telecommunication companies retroactive immunity, Chris Dodd has stepped in at the last minute and stopped the spying bill in its tracks! Read this breaking news from the Talking Points Memo:

Dodd will send a letter to Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid this afternoon informing him of his decision [to put a hold on the Senate FISA renewal bill because it reportedly grants retroactive immunity to telephone companies for any role they played in the Bush administration's warrantless eavesdropping program].

...By doing this, Dodd can effectively hold up the telecom immunity bill, because bills are supposed to have unanimous consent in the Senate before going forward. One Senator can make it very difficult to bring a bill to the floor by objecting to allowing it to go to a vote.

Dodd's planned action comes amid reports that the Senate Intelligence Committee has reached a deal with the White House on the legislation that would give telephone carriers legal immunity for whatever role they played in the National Security Agency's domestic eavesdropping program, which was approved by President Bush after 9/11. The White House and the phone companies have been lobbying aggressively for immunity, and the announcement of the immunity deal today dismayed many opponents.

Dodd's new web page petition on this is now live.

I'll be following this issue as events unfold.

Senate Grants Immunity to Telecomm Companies

Just when you thought the telecomm companies that sold out our privacy may have to answer to the people the Democrats buckle and grant them immunity! I'm of course speaking of companies like AT&T secretly providing our telephone records, e-mail traffic and other information to the Bush administration without our permission. Nevermind this is illegal, and nevermind that it was part of a larger illegal, and domestic, wiretapping program that targeted Americans.

Apparently, though we people have to abide by the law, telecommunication companies do not.

Here's an excellent summation of today's truly dissappointing news from the Center for American Progress:

SENATE GRANTS IMMUNITY TO TELECOMMUNICATIONS COMPANIES ON WIRETAPPING: Yesterday, the Senate reached an agreement with the Bush administration on a government surveillance bill that includes immunity for telecommunications companies who may have broken the law in the past by making client data available to the National Security Agency. President Bush has declared immunity to be a precondition to his signing the bill. But providing immunity "would wipe out a series of pending lawsuits alleging violations of privacy rights by telecommunications companies that provided telephone records, summaries of e-mail traffic and other information to the government after Sept. 11, 2001, without receiving court warrants." Cindy Cohn of the Electronic Frontier Foundation, the lead counsel in one such lawsuit against AT&T, said that these lawsuits are not the work of "typical trial lawyers trying to find a way to get into the pockets of American companies," as House Minority Leader John Boehner (R-OH) claimed. "It's certainly the goal of the administration and the phone companies to ensure that there's never a decision about [whether] what's been going on is legal or not. The telecom cases are the last, best hope," Cohn said. The House Democratic leadership yesterday had to pull its version of the bill, which does not contain telecom immunity, after Deputy Whip Eric Cantor (R-VA) introduced an amendment that would have "substantially delayed" the legislation.

But that's not all. As far as I can tell, the real "story" of the past few weeks is the fact that it appears the Bush Administration began illegally wiretapping Americans well BEFORE 9/11.

See here:

"After September the 11th...I authorized the National Security Agency to intercept the international communications of people with known links to al Qaeda and related terrorist organizations."

--President Bush, 5/11/06

VERSUS

"Former chief executive Joseph P. Nacchio...said the NSA approached Qwest more than six months before the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks [about surveillance contracts]."

--Washington Post, 10/13/07

This not only directly contradicts the President's assertion that the program began after 9/11, but it also decimates their entire contention that the program has always been about "catching terrorists". We of course all know that prior to 9/11 the Administration was focused on everything BUT terrorism. So, in light of these revelations, its gravely dissappointing to see the Democrats not only fail to raise this issue, but then buckle again by giving telecommunication companies immunity for their crimes!!

Constitutional law litigatore Glenn Greenwald states it nicely:

There is absolutely no justification whatsoever — neither substantive nor political — for expanding the scope of warrantless eavesdropping powers and especially for granting amnesty to lawbreaking telecoms. It is unconscionable even to consider any changes to FISA without full disclosure by the administration of how they used their illegal and secret warrantless eavesdropping powers in the past. In that regard, it is worth emphasizing that the administration from 2001 through 2004 (at least) was
engaged in spying on Americans so patently illegal that the entire top level of the DOJ and the FBI Director threatened to quit if it continued — yet we still do not know what they were doing then. How can that be?

There is no justification for permitting that conduct to remain concealed from the American public, let alone from the Congress.Warrantless eavesdropping and telecom amnesty implicate virtually every critical political value assaulted for the last six years by this administration — our basic constitutional protections, checks and balances and the rule of law. Capitulation by the Democratic Congress here would eliminate any residual doubt (if there is any) about what this Congress really is. We shouldn’t assume the worst unless and until it actually happens, and until it does, everything should be done to prevent that.

Tuesday, October 16, 2007

California Law Bans Forced Human RFID Tagging

E-Week.com covers the Governor's signing of SB 362 last week - Senator Simitian's subcutaneous implant bill. While a big victory for privacy advocates, the real test will be whether the Governor signs the Senators more ambitious RFID reform bills SB 28, 29, 30 and 31. Each of these were turned into two year bills, and could be heard in the Legislature as early as January 2008.

Renee Ferguson of E-Week writes:

It's illegal now for California employers to force anyone to have an RFID device implanted under his or her skin as a condition of receiving something—such as a paycheck or government benefits.

"RFID technology is not, in and of itself, the issue. RFID is a minor miracle, with all sorts of good uses," said Simitian, in Sacramento, Calif. "But we cannot and should not condone forced 'tagging' of humans. It's the ultimate invasion of privacy."

...

In the wake of the 2006 veto, Simitian took the next feasible step. He broke the Identity Information and Protection Act into smaller bits and shipped them off to the legislature as five separate bills. SB 362 is the first of those smaller bills to see the light of day, and it could have positive implications for the remaining four RFID bills trundling through California's legislative process.

"With the signing of SB 362, California has taken an important first step in crafting legislation to properly balance the potential benefits of RFID technology while safeguarding privacy and security," said Nicole Ozer, technology and civil liberties policy director at ACLU of Northern California, in San Francisco. "We are pleased that the governor has stood up for the privacy and security rights of Californians and not allowed these rights to be 'chipped' away by inappropriate uses of RFID technology."

...

SB 30—really the meat in Simitian's efforts—looks to mandate security and privacy provisions in RFID-chipped ID documentation required by state and local governments. The bill would do two things: require that people be informed when the technology is present and spell out what citizens can do to protect their privacy. The bill also imposes technological requirements that amount to password protection and, in cases where personal information—such as HIV-positive status or a telephone number—is present on the chip, encryption and mutual authentication technologies have to be utilized.

Read more from E-Week...

Monday, October 15, 2007

Governor vetoes AB 779 - Signs 1168 and 1298

The good news is three of the four privacy protection bills that made it to the Governors desk were signed. The bad news is that the most important of the four, at least from a consumer perspective, was vetoed.

As stated in the article in Security Focus, AB 779 "would have would have prevented companies from retaining certain sensitive payment data and spelled out what information firms would need to disclose in the event of a breach."

The bill had near unanimous support, overwhelmingly passing both the Assembly and the Senate. As pointed out by Frank Russo of the California Progress Report:

It received its final passage in the Assembly 73-0 in September with 47 of 48 Democrats in support and 26 of 32 Republicans voting for it. Before its final amendments it had previously passed the Assembly in June on a 58-2 vote. It passed the California State Senate on a 30 to 6 vote with the support of 22 of 25 Democrats and 8 of those often difficult 15 Republican Senators.

Unfortunately, as Russo also points out, and which helps explain why this popular and needed law was vetoed, there was a massive (and successful) lobbying effort in opposition to the bill initiated by two of the Governor's most powerful allies: the California Retailers Association and the California Chamber of Commerce.

Now to the good news. The Governor signed the following two Jones bills:

AB 1168 (Jones) would prohibit local government agencies from releasing to the public records that contain more than the last four digits of a social security number.

AB 1298 (Jones) would protect consumers' medical records by extending the state's existing medical privacy laws to the emerging electronic medical records industry.

Friday, October 12, 2007

Governor signs SB 362 - Simitian's RFID Bill!!

We just got the news! There aren't any press stories about the signing yet, as we got word just after lunch time today that the Governor has signed SB 362 (Identification devices: subcutaneous implanting). The new law will prohibit a person or business from requiring, coercing, or compelling any other individual to undergo the subcutaneous implanting of an identification device.

The Consumer Federation of California actively supported this legislation, stating:

"...the FDA has approved a subdermal RFID-enabled device for people, and that product has been developed and is being marketed in the U.S. and abroad. While subdermal RFID has some promise when used voluntarily, it comes with the same security and privacy risks associated with other RFID-enabled products. And because it is inserted underneath the skin and is difficult and costly to remove, subdermal RFID presents a Pandora’s Box of policy questions in addition to its profound implications for our constitutionally protected rights to freedom and privacy.

This is not a road we need to travel. It is simply not appropriate for anyone to force, compel or coerce anyone to accept a subdermal RFID-enabled identification implant. And though it sounds Matrix-like, this possibility exists now and is getting more real every day. For these reasons, the Consumer Federation of California supports SB 362. "

For more on the bill and issue, and for those new to the site, check out this excellent editorial by the San Francisco Chronicle we posted here in August.

The Chronicle states:

"Just last year, a Cincinnati-based provider of video-surveillance equipment inserted glass-encapsulated microchips into the arms of two employees to increase the level of security to the company's datacenter.

Those two workers volunteered, but it's not hard to imagine the lightbulbs going off in Corporate America. Is Joe really making a sales call or is he taking in a baseball game at AT&T Park? How many smoke breaks is Mary taking?

Amazingly, there is no California law against "chipping" workers as a condition of employment. Even more incredible -- outrageous, really -- is the resistance state Sen. Joe Simitian, D-Palo Alto, has encountered in trying to pass legislation (SB362) that would prevent an employer or anyone else, including government, from coercing an individual to accept a microchip implant."

Thursday, October 11, 2007

Privacy bills still sit on Governor's desk

Advocates across California are waiting with held breath the Governor's decision on a handful of privacy protection bills. The deadline for a signature or a veto is October 14th. Here's a list of the most important legislation to keep an eye out for, with accompanying links to additional information, including fact sheets and support letters:

AB 779 (Jones) would require retailers to reimburse data breach-related costs, disclose more details about breaches, and prohibit retailers and other merchants from storing specific types of authentication data.

AB 1168 (Jones) would prohibit local government agencies from releasing to the public records that contain more than the last four digits of a social security number.

AB 1298 (Jones) would protect consumers' medical records by extending the state's existing medical privacy laws to the emerging electronic medical records industry.

SB 362 (Simitian) would prohibit a person or business from requiring, coercing, or compelling any other individual to undergo the subcutaneous implanting of an identification device.

We'll be watching the Governor's actions closely the next few days!