Wednesday, October 31, 2007

Senate panel's report details divisions over spy measure

CongressDaily reports on the continued debate taking place in the Senate Intelligence Committee over the issue of wiretapping. As the legislation heads to the Senate Floor, there remains significant areas of contention, with Senators like Feingold and Widen on one side, and Republicans and a few Democrats on the other.

Chris Strohm writes:

Taking exception with the majority view, Sens. Ron Wyden, D-Ore., and Russell Feingold, D-Wis., criticize the committee for not adopting three amendments they offered. One amendment would have given the secret FISA court a greater role in overseeing the administration's spying activities. They said the amendment's defeat "leaves in place what we believe are inadequate mechanisms for protecting the privacy of Americans' communications." Another amendment would have limited how the administration can use information collected about U.S. citizens or legal residents...A third amendment would have required all provisions in the bill to expire at the end of December 2009, rather than December 2013.

...

The senators wrote that the amendment's language has "significant technical and legal problems...that would cause the intelligence community to lose valuable intelligence on certain U.S. persons who are spying for a foreign power or supporting terrorism." They added that they "remain hopeful that we will be able to reach a compromise on this issue when we get to the floor."

Tuesday, October 30, 2007

Details on Surveillance Released by Administration

The Wall Street Journal is reporting that the White House has bowed to pressure from Congress and will release various surveillance related documents. Of course there is still major work to be done by Congress - tabling the offer to give telecomm companies retroactive immunity comes immediately to mind.

Evan Perez writes:

The report, which accompanies and explains the reasons behind the Senate Intelligence Committee’s approval of an update to the law that oversees government intelligence surveillance activities, gives incremental new details of how the White House deployed a now contentious program run by the National Security Agency without seeking court warrants. The committee’s update to the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, or FISA, contains a clause granting legal immunity to telecom providers that assisted the program, a measure that has met with strong opposition from other members of Congress.

...

The reference to the letter not endorsed by the attorney general may refer to a period in 2003 when several Justice Department lawyers, including James Comey, then deputy attorney general, refused to sign off on aspects of the NSA program because they believed it was illegal. Mr. Comey ended up having a confrontation with Andrew Card, former White House chief of staff, and Alberto Gonzales, then White House counsel and later attorney general, at the hospital bedside of John Ashcroft, over his refusal to approve the program. The report’s description suggests that the administration may have sent letters containing only White House legal endorsement while it quelled the uprising at the Justice Department.

It appears to me that there are really two distinct programs being discussed here, or at least two distinct lengths the Administration would go to circumvent the Consititution and wiretap Americans. There's the program that we generally know, which is illegal in itself, and then there's the program that was shot down by Ashcroft and Comey on his "deathbed". This attempt by the administration to pressure Ashcroft into supporting this yet to be known "plan" led to a near mass exodus of Justice Department employees.

Clearly then, we have yet to scratch the surface of how far this administration was trying to go...and what privacy rights would have been lost if they were successful. The question is when, or if, we'll ever get to find out exactly what they were asking Ashroft to sign off on that night in the hospital.

Monday, October 29, 2007

Moyers: ‘When the President Does it, That Means That it is Not Illegal’

Watch this poignant editorial by Bill Moyers on wiretapping, FISA, and the Constitution. "Crooks and Liars" sets the clip up:

In 1975 the Select Senate Committee headed by Sen Frank Church (D-ID) began looking into allegations first reported by Seymour Hersh in the NYT and found that the CIA, NSA, FBI and other federal agencies had been involved in everything from plots to assassinate foreign leaders, illegal storage of poisons and biological warfare agents including anthrax, warrantless opening of mail and wiretapping and other intel-gathering on US citizens, and misuse of the IRS , just to name a few of the abuses by the Executive Branch they discovered. One of the ways Congress responded to try and restore checks and balances was by passing the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) of 1978, which established a secret court to oversee all domestic wiretapping activity. Bill Moyers looks at the undoing of Congress’ checks and balances put in place following the Church Committee hearings and the unprecedented expansion of Executive authority in the wake of 9-11. You can watch the entire episode online here.

Friday, October 26, 2007

WH cut domestic spying deal: Documents for Telecom Immunity

Surprise, surprise. In order to protect their partners in crime - the telecomm industry - the White House cut a deal with select members of the Senate Intelligence Committee. In exchange for giving the telcomm industry rectroactive immunity from prosecution for giving up customers' private personal information to the government, members got to actually view documents related to the illegal wiretapping program they had yet to see! How kind of the administration!

Thankfully, Judiciary Committee Chair Pat Leahy, nor the ranking member, Arlen Specter, are to keen on this quid pro quo.

The Washington Post reports:

Senate Judiciary Committee members yesterday angrily accused the White House of allowing the Senate Intelligence Committee to review documents on its warrantless surveillance program in return for agreeing that telecommunications companies should get immunity from lawsuits.

...

At issue is a White House-endorsed measure that would give immunity to telecom carriers being sued for allegedly helping the National Security Agency spy on Americans after September 11, 2001. It is part of a larger bill to rework the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA). The Intelligence Committee has approved the bill and sent it to the Judiciary Committee for deliberation.

...

Sen. Russell Feingold (D-Wis.), a member of both the Intelligence and Judiciary panels, said in an interview yesterday that the documents revealed that the NSA program was illegal. He said the presidential authorizations and the Justice Department opinions do not make it legal. "That makes it an executive power grab that is not justified by the statute or by the Constitution," he said.

...

Everything he saw and reported to me would indicate that the terrorist surveillance program involved was illegal and not something permissible given the clear exclusivity language in the statute," said Feingold, referring to current law, which specifies that FISA, along with Title III of the 1968 Wiretap Act, shall be the "exclusive" means to authorize domestic wiretaps. Feingold voted against the bill, which would allow the government to begin wiretaps of foreign targets and then seek FISA court approval of the targeting procedures...Feingold said that the documents revealed "the absence of a legitimate justification under the law" for the program.

Washington Post blogger Andrew Cohen sums up the shady backdoor dealings aptly:

What a warped world...the White House may have selectively shared sensitive information about its warrantless surveillance program based on which lawmakers supported legal immunity for telecom companies that cooperated with the legally dubious program.

...

To make a questionable situation all the more distasteful, the New York Times reported yesterday that Senate Intelligence Chair John D. Rockefeller IV (D-W.Va.) received tens of thousands of dollars in political contributions from telecom executives. Did Rockefeller become one of the strongest supporters of immunity because of White House pressure? Or did he take that position to appease his contributors? Either way, it doesn't look good.

...

Lawmakers must ensure that their new surveillance bill has better judicial and congressional oversight than the previous version. They should also consider whether there is a compelling reason to protect the assets of big corporations at the expense of individual privacy. This story, though, is rapidly becoming a symbol for all that is wrong with the legal war on terror.

Thursday, October 25, 2007

Leahy, Specter Intro ID Theft Bill to Give Victims Redress

To follow up on the post from yesterday, it appears the Senate has taken notice to the issue of identity theft and the need for increased security and protection of privacy as well as stronger penalties for perpetrators. The Personal Data Privacy and Security Act (S. 495), introduced by Senators Leahy and Specter (the bill will be helped by the fact that these two are the Chairman and Ranking Member of the Judiciary Committee), would take a number of positive steps on consumers' behalf.

Among others, these include:

  • Give victims of identity theft the ability to seek restitution for the loss of time and money spent restoring credit and remedying the harms of identity theft
  • Expand the jurisdiction of federal computer fraud statutes to cover small businesses and corporations
  • Eliminate the prosecutorial requirement that sensitive identity information must have been stolen through an interstate or foreign communication and instead focuses on whether the victim's computer is used in interstate or foreign commerce, allowing for the prosecutions of cases in which both the identify thief's computer and the victim's computer are located in the same state

Senator Leahy stated, "Protecting American consumers from identity theft and fraud should be one of the Senate's top priorities. Cyber criminals are getting smarter and more effective in their online efforts to strip Americans of their privacy, and their property. We can't afford to stand still while they find new ways to get around our laws and our crime-fighting tactics. This is a bill to help us stay ahead of the curve in prosecuting these cyber crimes. Senator Specter and I are committed to moving forward with this aggressive and important privacy legislation."

Click here to read the full article.

Wednesday, October 24, 2007

More Identity Theft In Mobile Phones, Computers Than On Internet

I suppose this may come as somewhat of a surprise, but according to a new study by Utica College's Center for Identity Management and Information Protection, technology like printers, mobile phones and computers were used in about half of cases of identity theft - far more than the internet.

AHN News reports on key findings from a number of new studies about identity theft, from who is the typical offender, how much it costs consumers every year, to what technologies are most susceptible to it.

Paul Icamina writes:

According to the study released Monday, identity theft is widespread in the northeastern and southern United States. Most of the offenders were African-Americans, of which more than two-thirds were male.

The average loss from identity theft was just over $31,000, PC World reports. But in one case, the defendant spent millions on luxury vehicles and then managed to set up shell companies and defraud investors at the cost of $13 million.

...

ID thieves victimize people that they did not know rather than friends and relatives which are the victims in 16 percent of cases. One-third of cases involved an inside job with the data being stolen from an employer, according to the study.

Monday, October 22, 2007

Big Steps Forward - But a Long Way to Go

I don't want to beat a dead horse, but one more look at the past year's successes and failures in California on the issue of identity theft is in order. Who better to give some context and perspective on the year that was than consumer champion Dave Jones (D-Assembly), who authored three identity theft protection bills that made it to the Governor's desk (2 signed, 1 vetoed).

Read the Assemblyman's editorial in the California Progress Report:

Early this year my staff logged onto the Secretary of State’s website, entered some credit card information, and purchased the social security numbers of two of the most successful businessmen in Sacramento. For $6 each.

...

It’s now common knowledge that the SSN is the backbone of ID theft; it props up the entire $53 billion-per-year criminal venture...That’s why I’m very pleased that over the last weekend Governor Schwarzenegger signed my bill, AB 1168, into law. Under AB 1168, the Franchise Tax Board, the Secretary of State, and all 58 county recorders would have to truncate SSNs in records they hold so that no more than the last 4 digits are displayed to the public.

...

Unfortunately, my highest profile privacy bill, AB 779, was vetoed by the Governor on October 13th. AB 779 would have required retailers and government to better protect their customers’ personal information that far too often is left open for hackers and ID thieves to pilfer as part of massive data breaches. In addition to avoiding future data breaches the bill would have better informed consumers after a breach takes place and made retailers and government partially responsible for the financial costs of data breaches. This space had previously written about AB 779 as it was moving through the Legislature.

...

However, the story behind the AB 779 veto is a simple one. Special business interests won over the public interest. Despite our broad coalition and overwhelming bipartisan support, numerous business interests, led by the California Retailers Association, the California Bankers Association, and the California Chamber of Commerce all urged a veto. So despite evidence showing 1) that only 40% of the nation’s largest retail chains are following current private data security rules, 2) that credit card fraud linked to data breaches is at an all-time high and 3) that the American Bankers Association and other state banking associations have either strenuously criticized retailer security or sued following major data breaches, the Governor acted as if the marketplace was working swimmingly and vetoed my bill. I’m obviously disappointed but remain unbowed, as I know that in the long run we will emerge victorious on this issue.

Read more...