Tuesday, September 8, 2009

The Emerging Privacy Threat Posed by Smart Meters (and their enormous potential)

There is a critically important debate emerging throughout the country regarding the privacy consequences, implications and challenges that smart grid or smart metering technologies pose and how they can most effectively be addressed.

I delved into this subject quite deeply a few months ago in a post entitled The Privacy Challenges and Implications of a "Smart Grid". Since that time I have become more deeply involved in this issue in hopes of ensuring that the corporate interests seeking to maximize profit are not successful in portraying themselves as environmentally conscious stewards of the planet - and that protecting consumer privacy would somehow threaten this great mission.

The fact is that smart and effective environmental policy does not, and should not, conflict with the individuals right to privacy. Our society's transition to a smart grid system epitomizes this emerging and unnecessary "conflict" - and thus critical that we address it now - while this transition is still in the early stages of implementation.

It is because of this emerging false choice between the environment and privacy that we (Consumer Federation of California) are currently engaging the California Public Utilities Commission as they deliberate how to best implement a "smart grid" system.

Let me give some more backdrop in this issue by quoting some of what I wrote back in June of this year:

Transition to a "Smart Grid" system has been trumpeted by former Vice President Al Gore, and started gaining serious traction once President Obama announced his plan to overhaul U.S. infrastructure - including construction of a nationwide "smart grid" that promises to help address many of our current energy challenges.

According to Obama (and other environmental experts), the plan offers the hope that it "will save us money, protect our power sources from blackout or attack, and deliver clean, alternative forms of energy to every corner of our nation." What is especially interesting about this topic - to me anyway - stems from my past work as an environmental advocate versus my current work on privacy related issues. As some of you may have gathered, there are some issues in which these two interests - privacy and environment - clash (all be it more "gently" than other more typical oppositional interests).

Privacy is a concern when talking about a transition to a "smart grid" system because of the kinds of high resolution electricity usage information that it compiles and the intimate details of a consumer's daily life it monitors. This information in turn could then be used in ways potentially invasive to an individuals privacy.On the other hand, the environmental benefits of such a system, specifically the reduction in energy usage and greenhouse gas emissions (among others), represent a critical step forward and an important component to any comprehensive global warming and sustainability strategy.

And therein lies the challenge with a "Smart Grid": How do we balance the privacy concerns of the individual with the important environmental and energy security benefits of a more efficient energy infrastructure? Clearly, this is a challenge that must be worked out, and soon.While climate change threatens our species longterm survival, our right to privacy continues to be subverted by big business interests (esp. marketing and advertisers) and the government (esp. in the age of the phony 'war on terror').

The rapid advancement of technological innovation - without the requisite regulations to go along with them - only adds to this growing privacy protection challenge...which the development of a "Smart Grid" epitomizes.

Now let's get to the article that addresses this very topic in the Philadelphia Inquirer:

The meters could record material so frequently that power flows could be interpreted like DNA to reveal unique electrical signatures of individual appliances. Some experts imagine an Orwellian future in a carbon-constrained world, where consumers are cited for excessive electricity use, or divorce lawyers comb through meter records and ask: Who used the hot tub while the spouse was away?

...

Smart meters also will allow utilities to shut customers off remotely; currently, a crew has to physically disconnect the meter. They also will improve utilities' ability to detect and manage outages. But because they capture so much information, the meters also can reveal intimate details about activity inside a customer's house: when they are home; when they sleep; when they eat.

...

Analysts are only beginning to exploit the flood of data produced by the current generation of digital meters, which utilities such as Peco installed in the last decade to replace manual devices that had to be physically read every month by a meter reader.

Click here to read more.

I will be coming back to this topic a lot in the coming months, as I do feel it will be, and is already becoming, a critical issue for all those that care about privacy. Similarly, I believe it will serve as an opportunity for privacy and environmental advocates to demonstrate that we can work together in a way that protects both of our interests...and therefore those of the public as well.

There is no reason that privacy must be sacrificed at the alter of environmentalism - as protecting it will not reduce the potential of a smart grid system to reduce energy use. The real "enemy" is those that will seek to use these smart meters to gather, and then profit off our private information.

I can assure you that a key strategy that these corporate interests will utilize will be to pit those that advocate for privacy against those that work to address the environmental crisis we all face. We must not let this happen...and there is no better way to do this than by joining forces and working to ensure that our country's transition to a smart grid system is done in a way that protects the individuals right to privacy while helping reduce every households carbon footprint.

If you want to find out more about how this precisely can be done, I'd suggest you check out the recommendations made by Elias Leake Quinn CEES, Uni. Colo. Law School in his paper entitled "Privacy and the New Energy Infrastructure".

In one especially important passage he writes:

...the solution must involve, first and foremost, drawing attention to the potential privacy problem posed by the massive deployment of smart metering technologies and the collection of detailed information about the electricity consumption habits of millions of individuals. From there, efforts to devise potential solutions must progress in parallel paths, the first in search of a regulatory fix, the second a technological one. The first protects against the systematic misuse of collected information by utilities, despite new pressures on their profitability, by ensuring the databases are used only for their principle purposes: informing efficient electricity generation, distribution, and management. Such regulatory fixes are not difficult.

Indeed, Connecticut’s relevant regulations may already provide adequate protection against many of the “troubling implications” of this growing data set. Opt-in regulations are appropriate—at least in the short term—to protect consumers while the market for smart metering data develops and the full capabilities of those with access to that data are laid bare. As many states are taking a fresh look at their relevant regulations in connection with the restructuring of billing rates, swift action on this issue is both possible and easy.

The technological fix is a bit larger an obstacle, and solutions, on my part, more covered in lint. However, some recommendations are apparent even from this discussion. Specifically, the technological answer to these concerns must come in two parts: one addressing the security of the database as aggregated and kept by the utility, and the other addressing the security of transmitted data...One possible approach might be to aggregate and encrypt the data being sent from smart meters back to the utility by putting additional hardware on each transformer. This would basically anonymize an individual’s information to roughly the scale of a city block.

Click here to read the paper.

Wednesday, September 2, 2009

Consumer And Privacy Groups Urge Congress to Enact Consumer Privacy

Some very exciting news to report today! Yesterday a coalition of ten consumer and privacy advocacy organizations called on Congress to enact legislation to protect consumer privacy in response to threats from the growing practices of online behavioral tracking and targeting.

The coalition consists of the Consumer Federation of America, Center for Digital Democracy, Consumers Union, Consumer Watchdog, Electronic Frontier Foundation, Privacy Lives, Privacy Rights Clearinghouse, Privacy Times, U.S. Public Interest Research Group, and The World Privacy Forums.

This is a very impressive coalition speaking out on a very important privacy issue at a very important time.

So let me first give some backdrop on the issue of behavioral targeting on the Internet by quoting a few passages from the coalition's legislative primer entitled "Online Behavioral Tracking and Targeting Concerns and Solutions":

Privacy is a fundamental right in the United States. For four decades, the foundation of U.S. privacy policies has been based on Fair Information Practices: collection limitation, data quality, purpose specification, use limitation, security safeguards, openness, individual participation, and accountability.

Those principles ensure that individuals are able to control their personal information, help to protect human dignity, hold accountable organizations that collect personal data, promote good business practices, and limit the risk of identity theft. Developments in the digital age urgently require the application of Fair Information Practices to new business practices. Today, electronic information from consumers is collected, compiled, and sold; all done without reasonable safeguards.

Consumers are increasingly relying on the Internet and other digital services for a wide range of transactions and services, many of which involve their most sensitive affairs, including health, financial, and other personal matters. At the same time many companies are now engaging in behavioral advertising, which involves the surreptitious tracking and targeting of consumers.

Click by click, consumers’ online activities – the searches they make, the Web pages they visit, the content they view, the videos they watch and their other interactions on social networking sites, the content of emails they send and receive, how they spend money online, their physical locations using mobile Web devices, and other data – are logged into an expanding profile and analyzed in order to target them with more "relevant" advertising.

This is different from the "targeting" used in contextual advertising, in which ads are generated by a search that someone is conducting or a page the person is viewing at that moment. Behavioral tracking and targeting can combine a history of online activity across the Web with data derived offline to create even more detailed profiles. The data that is collected through behavioral tracking can, in some cases, reveal the identity of the person, but even when it does not, the tracking of individuals and the trade of personal or behavioral data raise many concerns.

The report also lays out a series of specific concerns:

Tracking people’s every move online is an invasion of privacy. Online behavioral tracking is even more distressing when consumers aren’t aware who is tracking them, that it’s happening, or how the information will be used. Often consumers are not asked for their consent and have no meaningful control over the collection and use of their information, often by third parties with which they have no relationships. Online behavioral tracking and targeting can be used to take advantage of vulnerable consumers.

Information about a consumer’s health, financial condition, age, sexual orientation, and other personal attributes can be inferred from online tracking and used to target the person for payday loans, sub-prime mortgages, bogus health cures and other dubious products and services. Children are an especially vulnerable target audience since they lack the capacity to evaluate ads.

Online behavioral tracking and targeting can be used to unfairly discriminate against consumers. Profiles of individuals, whether accurate or not, can result in "online redlining" in which some people are offered certain consumer products or services at higher costs or with less favorable terms than others, or denied access to goods and services altogether. Online behavioral profiles may be used for purposes beyond commercial purposes.

Internet Service Providers (ISPs), cell phone companies, online advertisers and virtually every business on the web retains critical data on individuals. In the absence of clear privacy laws and security standards these profiles leave individuals vulnerable to warrantless searches, attacks from identity thieves, child predators, domestic abusers and other criminals.

Also, despite a lack of accuracy, employers, divorce attorneys, and private investigators may find the information attractive and use the information against the interests of an individual. Individuals have no control over who has access to such information, how it is secured, and under what circumstances it may be obtained.

Before I get to more of the coalition's specific proposals to address these concerns, let me detail why I think this effort is coming at an ideal time. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) - as I have written about on this blog - has gone through some enormous positive changes under President Obama, and is apparently now committed to better protecting internet users from behavioral targeting and ads.

In a recent article in Business Week, FTC Chairman Jon Leibowitz, Obama's top consumer watchdog, said he wants to terminate—or at least rein in—delivering ads to individuals based on the Web pages they visit and searches they carry out (supporting the establishment of “opt-in” as the standard rather than “opt-out”).

Similarly, David C. Vladeck - the new head of the Bureau of Consumer Protection at the FCT – said in a New York Times article this week that the frameworks used historically for privacy on the web are no longer sufficient, and wants to expand the definition of what is considered “harm” to the consumer when a company infringes on their privacy to beyond solely a monetary measurement, but to whether their dignity was violated.

So two important signals (among others articulated in the articles) have been sent by Leibowitz and Vladek indicating the FTC is considering pushing for two essential legislative reforms (among many others) advocated by privacy leaders that would protect consumers: establishing "opt-in" as the standard and precedent and redefining what is considered “harm” to the consumer when his/her privacy is violated.

If ever enacted, each would represent a landmark improvement in protections for consumers against aggressive behavioral marketing techniques and industry data collection practices.

Before I get to the New York Times write up on the coalition's proposals to address behavioral targeting, let me provide some choice clips from their press release outlining some of their specific policy ideas as well as some choice quotes from privacy leaders:

“The rise of behavioral tracking has made it possible for consumer information to be almost invisibly tracked, complied and potentially misused on or offline. It’s critical that government enact strong privacy regulations whose protections will remain with consumers as they interact on their home computer, cell phones, PDAs or even at the store down the street. Clear rules will help consumers understand how their information is used, obtained and tracked,” said Amina Fazlullah of U.S. Public Interest Research Group. “In the event of abuse of consumer information, this legislation could provide consumers a clear pathway for assistance from government agencies or redress in the courts.”

“Respect for human dignity is at the core of our concerns, but we are also worried that online behavioral tracking can be used to target vulnerable consumers for high-price loans, bogus health cures and other potentially harmful products and services,” said Susan Grant, director of Consumer Protection at Consumer Federation of America.

“Limiting commercial tracking of our online activities may also help protect privacy against the government, which often gets information about us from private companies,” said Lee Tien, of the Electronic Frontier Foundation.

“The record is clear: industry self-regulation doesn't work,” said Beth Givens, Director of the Privacy Rights Clearinghouse “It is time for Congress to step in and codify the principles into law.”

...

Among the main points that the coalition said should be included in consumer privacy legislation:

· Sensitive information should not be collected or used for behavioral tracking or targeting.
· No behavioral data should be collected or used from anyone under age 18 to the extent that age can be inferred.
· Web sites and ad networks shouldn’t be able to collect or use behavioral data for more than 24 hours without getting the individual’s affirmative consent.
· Behavioral data shouldn’t be used to unfairly discriminate against people or in any way that would affect an individual's credit, education, employment, insurance, or access to government benefits.


Now let's get to the New York Times write up:

Privacy advocates, with their best chance in years to get new legislation limiting Internet targeting passed in Washington, are skipping their summer vacation this year.

...

Among the things they’re asking for: No sensitive information (like health or financial information) should be used for behavioral tracking, no one under 18 should be behaviorally tracked, Web sites and ad networks shouldn’t be able to keep behavioral data for more than a day without getting an OK from the individual they’re tracking, and behavioral data can’t be used for discriminatory purposes.

Some Congress members have indicated they will consider such legislation in the fall. That’s something industry has adamantly opposed. In July, industry groups offered new principles on how they would regulate tracking without government intervention They argue that legislation will lag the technology by a matter of years. Meanwhile, over at the Federal Trade Commission, David Vladeck, the new head of consumer protection, has indicated he has broader definitions of intrusive tracking than his predecessors did.

Click here to read the coalition press release, and here to read their detailed analysis and proposals for Congress to consider.

I don't think there's all that much for me to add here. Clearly these are critically important proposals for Congress to consider that will have an enormously positive impact on the future of consumer privacy on the Internet. There is nothing I can say that is not said better in the documents I have provided.

I can't really overstate how supportive I am of this work, and the proposals therein. Clearly some exhaustive work went into compiling this report and formulating these solutions to a growing problem and threat to individual privacy. A threat that will exponentially increase by the day if nothing is done. Now this will be a story I'll follow for you here!

Tuesday, September 1, 2009

NY Times: "A Casualty of the Technology Revolution: ‘Locational Privacy’"

Two weeks ago I wrote about a seminal a new report from the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) on the issue of "locational privacy". The report warns that Americans are losing their privacy as they travel through public space due to location-based technologies and services such as EZ Pass, Google Latitude and cellphones.

The good news is that EFF's work appears to be getting some welcomed attention, namely in the New York Times today. Before I get to today's article by Adam Cohen, let me provide, as I did two weeks ago, the definition of "Locational Privacy" - as articulated by EFF:

"...the ability of an individual to move in public space with the expectation that under normal circumstances their location will not be systematically and secretly recorded for later use. The systems discussed above have the potential to strip away locational privacy from individuals, making it possible for others to ask (and answer) the following sorts of questions by consulting the location databases:

• Did you go to an anti-war rally on Tuesday?
• A small meeting to plan the rally the week before?
• At the house of one “Bob Jackson”?
• Did you walk into an abortion clinic?
• Did you see an AIDS counselor?
• Have you been checking into a motel at lunchtimes?
• Why was your secretary with you?
• Did you skip lunch to pitch a new invention to a VC? Which one?
• Were you the person who anonymously tipped off safety regulators about the rusty machines?
• Did you and your VP for sales meet with ACME Ltd on Monday?
• Which church do you attend? Which mosque? Which gay bars?"
• Who is my ex-girlfriend going to dinner with?

EFF concluded with this important passage:

In the long run, the decision about when we retain our location privacy (and the limited circumstances under which we will surrender it) should be set by democratic action and lawmaking. Now is a key moment for organizations that are building and deploying location data infrastructure to show leadership and select designs that are responsible and do not surrender the locational privacy of users simply for expediency.

Now here's what New York Times reporter Adam Cohen had to say:

Privacy advocates are rightly concerned. Corporations and the government can keep track of what political meetings people attend, what bars and clubs they go to, whose homes they visit. It is the fact that people’s locations are being recorded “pervasively, silently, and cheaply that we’re worried about,” the Electronic Frontier Foundation said in a recent report.

People’s cellphones and E-ZPasses are increasingly being used against them in court. If your phone is on, even if you are not on a call, you may be able to be found (and perhaps picked up) at any hour of the day or night. As disturbing as it is to have your private data breached, it is worse to think that your physical location might fall into the hands of people who mean you harm.

...

What can be done? As much as possible, location-specific information should not be collected in the first place, or not in personally identifiable form. There are many ways, as the Electronic Frontier Foundation notes, to use cryptography and anonymization to protect locational privacy. To tell you about nearby coffee shops, a cellphone application needs to know where you are. It does not need to know who you are.

When locational information is collected, people should be given advance notice and a chance to opt out. Data should be erased as soon as its main purpose is met. After you pay your E-ZPass bill, there is no reason for the government to keep records of your travel.

Click here to read the article in its entirety.

All in all, I'd say this is a well done article and relatively important one at that - and a testament to the fine work of EFF too. As the author rightly points out, a constantly monitored citizenry used to conjure up images of totalitarian states - not Google and I-Phones. And granted, now technology does the surveillance — generally in the name of being helpful and entertaining, not to stifle dissent or oppress the public.

This fact does not mean that these technologies can't still be used in ways that do reduce freedoms, do play into the hands of overly aggressive and/or oppressive governments, and does invade privacy by using our private information to maximize corporate profit.

AS the author also rightly points out, "It’s time for a serious conversation about how much of our privacy of movement we want to give up."

Monday, August 31, 2009

The Privacy Implications and Challenges of Google Book Search

As I have written about fairly extensively on this blog, Google has developed a rather adversarial relationship with privacy advocates. The company's seeming disregard for privacy becomes only more serious a problem as its size and scope continues to expand and the corner it has on market after market keeps increasing.

Now, I've posted a lot about Google's less than stellar record in the past, from their lobbying efforts in Congress, to cloud computing, and to its increasing usage and expansion of behavioral marketing techniques. My guess is that if you didn't already know all the "problems" Google has in this area you'll be rather shocked to find out.

Now with the soon to be launch of Google Books just around the corner, privacy advocates have once again been forced to spring into action due to fears the company will give privacy short thrift.

Already, the ACLU, Electronic Frontier Foundation, and the Samuelson Clinic have launched a Google Book Search privacy campaign - one component of the ACLU-NC's dotrights project.

So what is "Google Book Search" and why are privacy advocates so concerned?

The ACLU does a good job framing the issue: What you choose to read says a lot about who you are, what you value, and what you believe. That’s why you should be able to learn about anything from politics to health without worrying that someone is looking over your shoulder.

The good news is that millions of books will be available for browsing and reading online. The bad news is that Google is leaving reader privacy behind. Under its current design, Google Book Search can monitor the books you browse, the pages you read, and even the notes you take in the "margins." Without strong privacy protections, all of your browsing and reading history could be collected, analyzed, and turned over to the government or third parties without your knowledge or consent.

In other words, without strong privacy protections, all of our browsing and reading history could be collected, analyzed, and turned over to the government or third parties without our knowledge or consent.

We're not talking about just another library mind you - librarians utilize a different standards for dealing with user information than does the online world. Many libraries routinely delete borrower information, and organizations such as the American Library Association have fought hard to preserve the privacy of their patrons in the face of laws such as the U.S. Patriot Act.

The concerns of privacy advocates are not hypothetical - nor should they be discarded as paranoia. Our country has a long history of government efforts to compel libraries and booksellers to turn over customer records and information. Why would anyone believe, particularly after the warrantless wiretapping scandal, that the government won't ask a company like Google to turn over the treasure trove of private personal information it has on millions of Americans?

For these reasons and more, it is essential that Google Book Search incorporate strong privacy protections. Without such protections, we're talking about a virtual one-stop shop for government and third party "fishing expeditions into the personal details of our lives."

Again, these concerns are not hypothetical. Just three years ago the U.S. attorney subpoenaed Amazon for the used book purchase records of over 24,000 customers in the course of a grand jury probe investigating a single individual.

The good news was a federal judge agreed that Amazon should not have to turn over this information about its customers, saying that if word spread over the Internet that the federal government was probing book purchase information , “the chilling effect on e-commerce would frost keyboards across America."

If there ever was a time to make sure that Google doesn't put an end to reader privacy as we know it would be now. At present, all Google has done is make a lot of informal statements about privacy, while failing to provide an actual privacy policy with specific promises to consumers.

Criticisms of Google aside, there is reason to believe that citizen and organization pressure on the company can and will pay dividends. After all, it has taken extra steps to preserve privacy with other offerings, from blurring faces on Google Maps Street View to keeping records for Google Health users separate from other Google services to not keeping a log of user locations with Google Latitude (not to say there aren't still concerns with these products).

After the article I'm featuring today, I'll also provide a brief list (and link to) specific recommendations advocated by the ACLU and sent to Google in hopes they will be adopted by the company.

Now to the editorial by Leslie Harris, president and CEO of the Center for Democracy & Technology:

...offline, the right to read anonymously enjoys strong constitutional protection. For decades, libraries have protected the rights of readers to remain anonymous. Such anonymity is protected by the First Amendment and is a cornerstone of intellectual and political freedom. Almost all states have library confidentiality laws. The question is whether and how Google will honor these protections as it designs and builds Google Book Search and develops policies to guide its use of customer data.

...

Under the proposed settlement, Google will be required to collect a substantial amount of information about the people who use Google Book Search. Google will need certain information to control how much content users access electronically (in most cases, users will have access to about 20 percent of a book's content before they must pay) and to track royalties due authors and publishers, among other things.

Even taken in a vacuum, the idea of a massive database of readers, cross-referenced by their reading preferences, choices and activities, raises serious privacy concerns. But those concerns are magnified when considered in the context of the sensitive personal information that Google already collects and controls. Through its broad array of applications and services, Google has access to a great deal of user information.

...

Combining reader information with its existing database of user information would allow Google to add a rich and intimately personal dimension to its profiles that could become very attractive to marketers, litigators, the government and others with an interest in profiting from sensitive personal data.

It's easy to see how such an environment could easily lead to significant privacy exposures, especially given the absence of a comprehensive federal consumer privacy law.

Taking thoughtful steps to protect privacy now will help to ensure that Google Book Search lives up to its promise as a powerful social good, rather than becoming the next lightning rod in our ongoing national debate over privacy on the Internet.

...

First and foremost, Google must make absolutely clear to its users what information it is collecting, and how that information will be used. While such notice is a linchpin of all privacy policies, Google Book Search should strive to set a new bar for clarity and conspicuousness. Readers should know exactly what they're getting, and exactly what they're giving up in return.

The recommendations also call on Google to establish limits so that it collects only the information it needs to complete Google Book Search transactions. For instance, Google shouldn't have to collect or store significant information about how users are accessing books online (what pages they read, their annotations, etc.). Google's default position must be, "if we don't need it, we won't collect it."

It is also critical that Google limit how it uses the information it is required to collect about users. If such information is needed to calculate payments to publishers, then it should be used for that purpose and no other. Reader data is simply too sensitive to be lumped indiscriminately into online marketing dossiers.

Most importantly, Google should commit to take strong steps when others, including the government, demand reader information.

...

With the settlement hearing fast approaching, Google has an opportunity to set a high standard for online reader privacy that will set a precedent for all who follow: first, by publishing a strong privacy policy for the service that covers the full range of issues raised by privacy advocates and, second, by pledging adherence to that commitment in its filing with the court. With so many issues likely to be raised before the settlement judge, taking the privacy concerns off the table now is good for Google, as well as for readers everywhere

Click here to read the rest of the editorial.

For a bit more details on what a strong privacy policy would look like, I suggest you check out the ACLU's recommendations.

Here's a brief summary of what they have urged:

Protection Against Disclosure: Readers should be able to use Google books without worrying that the government or a third party is reading over their shoulder. Google must promise that it will protect reader records by responding only to properly-issued warrants from law enforcement and court orders from third parties.

Limited Tracking: Just as readers can anonymously browse books in a library or bookstore, they should be able to anonymously browse, search, and preview books using Google Book Search. Google must allow users to browse, search, and preview books without being forced to register or provide any personal information.

User Control: Readers should have complete control of their purchases and purchasing data. Readers must be able to review and delete their records and have extensive permissions controls for their "bookshelves" or any other reading displays.

User Transparency: Readers should know what information is being collected and maintained about them and when and why reader information has been disclosed. Google must develop a robust privacy policy and publish annually the number and type of demands for reader information that are received.

Stay tuned...I'll reporting on developments as they come to light.

Friday, August 28, 2009

DHS Revises Border Laptop Search Rules - ACLU Not Satisfied

I'm doing a follow up on yesterday's post about the ACLU's lawsuit demanding that U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) release details of its policy that allows the agency to search travelers' laptops at U.S. borders without suspicion of wrongdoing.

It appears that the government has at least been pressured into attempting to address (though inadequately) complaints by privacy advocates that the CBP policy violates the Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, protecting U.S. citizens against unreasonable search and seizure.

The CBP policy allows agents to conduct searches of "documents, books, pamphlets and other printed material, as well as computers, disks, hard drives and other electronic or digital storage devices," without suspicion of a crime.

I do take some solace that this issue also made it into the Washington Post today. I am consistently dismayed by what short thrift the issue of privacy seems to get in today's mainstream media - particularly in light of the Obama Administration's adoption of nearly all of what many believe were the Bush team's unconstitutional approaches to "national security".

Before I get to the Post article, here's today's follow up in PC World:

The new guidelines, unveiled Thursday, continue to allow U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) and U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) to search electronic devices during border crossings without suspicion of wrongdoing. Both CBP and ICE are part of DHS.

The new rules were announced by DHS a day after the ACLU filed a lawsuit in an effort to get more information about border laptop searches. The ACLU and other groups have complained that the laptop search policy violates the U.S. Constitution's Fourth Amendment against unreasonable search and seizure.

...

The guidelines require CBP to complete a search of an electronic device within five days and ICE to complete a search within 30 days. In addition, agents must take additional steps to inform and educate travelers about the searches, and the DHS Office for Civil Rights and Civil Liberties will conduct an assessment of the policy's impact on civil rights within 120 days, Chandler said.

...

"DHS' latest policy announcement on border searches is a disappointment and should not be mistaken for one that restores the constitutional rights of travelers at the border," she said. "Members of the public deserve fundamental privacy rights when traveling and the safety of knowing that federal agents cannot rifle through their laptops without some reasonable suspicion of wrongdoing."

The ACLU does not oppose border searches, she added. "But it does oppose a policy that leaves government officials free to exercise their power arbitrarily," Crump said. "Such a policy not only invades our privacy but can lead to racial and religious profiling."

Click here to read the article in its entirety.

Now here are some choice clips from the Washington Post piece:

The Obama administration will largely preserve Bush-era procedures allowing the government to search -- without suspicion of wrongdoing -- the contents of a traveler's laptop computer, cellphone or other electronic device, although officials said new policies would expand oversight of such inspections.

The policy, disclosed Thursday in a pair of Department of Homeland Security directives, describes more fully than did the Bush administration the procedures by which travelers' laptops, iPods, cameras and other digital devices can be searched and seized when they cross a U.S. border. And it sets time limits for completing searches.

...

"It's a disappointing ratification of the suspicionless search policy put in place by the Bush administration," said Catherine Crump, staff attorney for the American Civil Liberties Union. "It provides a lot of procedural safeguards, but it doesn't deal with the fundamental problem, which is that under the policy, government officials are free to search people's laptops and cellphones for any reason whatsoever."

...

Under the policy begun by Bush and now continued by Obama, the government can open your laptop and read your medical records, financial records, e-mails, work product and personal correspondence -- all without any suspicion of illegal activity," said Elizabeth Goitein, who leads the liberty and national security project at the nonprofit Brennan Center for Justice.

Goitein, formerly a counsel to Sen. Russell Feingold (D-Wis.), said the Bush policy itself "broke sharply" with previous Customs directives, which required reasonable suspicion before agents could read the contents of documents. Feingold last year introduced legislation to restore the requirement.

Click here to read the rest of the article.

Again, I just feel there's something especially invasive about the government - or anyone for that matter - searching through my laptop. Let's face it, laptops are practically like a diary these days...there simply is almost NOTHING that I have that isn't on my computer. I am wholeheartedly with the ACLU on this.

I hate to always go back to the "slippery slope" argument - because it is often overused and misused by people trying to make a political point - but it really applies here. We're talking about seizing laptops without any suspicion of wrongdoing! The ways and degrees to which such a right could be abused by the government sends shivers down my spine (I'll get into what I believe some of the ways this could be done in the next post on this topic).

Thursday, August 27, 2009

ACLU Seeks (and Sues for) Information on Border Laptop Searches

As usual, the ACLU is on the front lines of the battle to protect the public from the growing power of government to bypass the 4th Amendment in the name of national security. One place this expansion of government power is especially glaring has been at, and even around the US border to Mexico. I guess its always easier to rationalize draconian, "constitution free" border policies when people are convinced they should be afraid of foreigners, terrorists, and of course, Mexicans.

Last year I wrote about the ACLU's efforts to challenge what were called "border patrol zones" - which essentially allow government agents to stop and question people anywhere without suspicion within 100 miles of the border. This little known power of the federal government to set up immigration checkpoints far from the nation's border lines came about after 9/11, when Congress gave the Department of Homeland Security the right to use some of its powers deeper within the country.

According to the ACLU last October, DHS had set up at least 33 internal checkpoints where they stop people, question them and ask them to prove citizenship. At that time I noted that if we allow these kinds of constitutional violations along our border, how long will it take before we start allowing them in the heartland? And I tend to be of the opinion that anytime we weaken the fundamental principles of our Constitution for ANYONE, we weaken them for EVERYONE.

As I also said, that as time goes by, and we see our right to privacy whittled away, watered down, or outright eviscerated, we similarly will see our belief in that right and principle weakened, our confidence in them shaken, and our reverence of them debased.

Now, ACLU has filed a lawsuit demanding that U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) release details of its policy that allows the agency to search travelers' laptops at U.S. borders without suspicion of wrongdoing.

PC World Reports:

The FOIA request and the lawsuit seek details about the laptop search policy, including how many laptops have been searched since the CBP instituted its search policy last year, Crump said. "Traveling with a laptop shouldn't mean the government gets a free pass to rifle through your personal papers," she said.

The ACLU and other civil liberties groups have complained that the CBP policy violates the Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, protecting U.S. citizens against unreasonable search and seizure.

The ACLU also wants to know how many laptops and electronic devices CBP has seized, how long CBP has kept those devices, and statistics about the race and ethnicity of the people whose laptops have been seized, according to the ACLU's FOIA request.

...

The CBP policy also allows the agency to conduct searches of "documents, books, pamphlets and other printed material, as well as computers, disks, hard drives and other electronic or digital storage devices," without suspicion of a crime.

Several Democratic members of the U.S. Congress have pushed for a change in the policy. The requested documents would be "enormously useful" for lawmakers debating the CBP policy, Crump said.

Another issue I'll be following...Click here to read the rest of the article.

Tuesday, August 25, 2009

What Can Google Do to Address Privacy Concerns?

This is a question I'd like to pose to some of my privacy expert friends, as I'm sure there are a slew of suggestions as to how exactly this could be effectively done by Google. For the sake of today's post, I'm just going to focus on some ideas posed by Thomas Claburn of Information Week.

So to be clear, these are only a few suggestions for Google from one writer - and not meant to be a comprehensive list in and of itself.

As I have written about fairly extensively on this blog, Google has developed an adversarial relationship with privacy advocates and a bordering on disdain for privacy rights and protections. If you don't believe me I'd suggest you check out some or all my prior posts on the subject.

My guess is that if you didn't already know all the "problems" Google has in this area you'll be rather shocked to find out. My last post on the subject was about two weeks ago and it delved into the growing concern over "locational privacy" as individuals move through public space.

But let's get to today. Information Week reports:

Google, which presumably launched Street View in Switzerland last week with full knowledge of all the other privacy controversies related to Street View and the company's other online services, nonetheless said it was surprised by the data commissioner's statement and that it's working with Swiss officials to deliver a service that conforms with Swiss law. That Google can still be surprised by privacy concerns is in itself surprising and suggests the company ought to approach privacy more proactively.

...

Privacy just doesn't seem to matter much in Google's data-driven world because privacy isn't something that's easily quantified. Google reinforced that view when it refused to put a link to its privacy policy on its home page and later relented when it found that the link could be added without slowing the home page load time.

Even Apple picked up the privacy stick to whack the Google pinata: In its recent response to the FCC inquiry into Apple's refusal to approve the Google Voice app for the iPhone, Apple cited privacy concerns as one of the reasons that it has not approved the application. "[T]he iPhone user's entire Contacts database is transferred to Google’s servers, and we have yet to obtain any assurances from Google that this data will only be used in appropriate ways," the company said.

...

Google ought to make privacy a priority. Not just as a matter of public relations...but as a core feature of its services. What would that look like? Google could:

• Allow users to choose not to have any search data retained

• Allow users to encrypt the data they store with Google

• Make users have to opt-in to behavioral ad targeting rather than opt-out

• Put its privacy enhancing tools, like license plate and face blurring algorithms for Street View, into an online service so that users themselves can flag invasive images

• Back legislation to establish a mechanism by which consumers can find out what information companies have about them and correct or remove that information

Click here to read the article in its entirety.

I'd welcome other suggestions for what concrete, positive steps Google could take in addressing the issue of privacy from anyone reading this blog today. In general, the ideas laid out in this article match up very well with many of the kinds of policies and principles I and others have argued for too. I would also agree with the author's other important thesis: That it would be in Google's own self interest to do so!

What I find disturbing is that the suggestions advocated in this article aren't ALREADY law or common policy. The right to not have my personal data shared and profited off and the right to have the option to choose what happens to that information and how well its protected seems to me to be a fundamental right protected in our constitution.