Monday, July 6, 2009

Protect Privacy: Demand Abandoned Business Records be Destroyed

I'm going to get into the latest on the Obama Administration's Cybersecurity Act and deep concerns that aspects of the NSA's Bush era monitoring program might be included in it tomorrow.

Today, I want to get to another one of our (The Consumer Federation of California) top privacy protection priorities this year that has recently garnered some media attention. I am referring to AB 1094 (Conway) and the need to institute stricter regulations of abandoned employee records that might contain personal, private information like a social security number.

Think about it: Do you really want to find out that abandoned records from a past employer that include your private information were found in the trash or on a hard drive, and are now being sold on eBay?

Believe it or not, this bill is the first in the nation designed to prevent this rather new and unique form of privacy invasion, and even identity theft.

Currently, when a business which ceases to operate, it is free to dispose of its records with little restriction even if these records contain personal information of its employees such as social security numbers.

AB 1094 would address this problem by requiring a business to treat abandoned records containing employee information with as much care as those records of consumers. An employer would have to ensure that all personal information is made unreadable before disposal.

This bill goes even further and creates incentives for entities such as storage facilities to also dispose of records containing personal information in a manner that is designed to protect a person's privacy.

The good news is I found an article explaing why this problem should be a concern to all those that value privacy, and how this particular bill will help solve it, in today's San Francisco Chronicle. Here's a few highlights from the article:

Every year, businesses go under and disappear, leaving behind boxes of transaction records, Social Security numbers and other sensitive information that could lead to identity theft and other forms of fraud. Landlords and owners of storage companies, who tend to get stuck holding these records, have no legal way to dispose of them and are paying thousands of dollars to store them. And the recession has only made the situation worse.

...

California is particularly hard hit by this problem because of the number of mortgage companies, title companies and brokerages that have disappeared. According to a survey done by Prism International, a trade group for information management, storage companies in California last year had to deal with an average of 29,110 cubic feet of abandoned records. Storing the records cost over $94,000, and shredding them cost $72,775.

...

Under the bill, holders of unwanted records could not be sued if records, including electronic records, were properly destroyed - if paper records were shredded, for example, or hard drives were wiped so the information is unreadable. Publicly available information is exempt, which means envelopes with names and addresses on them could simply be thrown away... next step is to convene experts to help her develop guidelines on how owners of abandoned records might be contacted and how records should be destroyed.

The good news is there has been next to no opposition to this legislation, and it appears guaranteed of passage. I think the more noteworthy aspect to this story, and this bill (hence why I am posting about it today), is that its the first of its kind to deal with a privacy threat that is relatively new - and which most Americans are largely unaware. Most importantly, as is often the case with California and our innovative approaches to public policy, other states will follow our example...something surely to be true in the case of AB 1094.

Click here to read the rest of the article.

Tuesday, June 30, 2009

Supreme Court Rejects Banks Appeal to California's Financial Privacy Law!!

Finally! The banking industry's 6 year campaign to overturn California's landmark financial privacy law is over...dead...kaput...or at least, so says the Supreme Court! Of course, I want to be measured in my response, so let me just reiterate what a friend of mine wrote me, "Woooo hoooo!!!"

I've written about this extensively in recent months, but I'll still give a brief review: For three years the Consumer Federation of California and other privacy advocates worked to enact a law that would give consumers the right to stop banks and other financial institutions from sharing their personal information - including with "affiliates" (which can number in the thousands).

This was achieved when Senate Bill 1 of 2003 (Speier) became law and California established the nation's strongest financial privacy protections. As soon as SB 1 was signed, the financial institutions ran to court to overturn it, arguing that other federal banking laws prevented state regulation of banks and brokerages.

In September 2008, the 9th Circuit declared the right of California consumers to stop disclosure of their personal information among affiliated financial institutions, except where such information was a consumer report. It was soon after that the Supreme Court became poised to take the Banking Industry lobby's appeal and possibly overturn portions of one of the most important victories for privacy advocates in recent memory.

On March 9th, the Supreme Court invited the Obama Administration to voice its opinion. In light of this news, a coalition of privacy groups joined forces to author an open letter to the Obama Administration urging it to defend California's landmark financial privacy law against the banking industry's legal efforts to overturn it. A copy of our coalition's letter to the President and the Solicitor General can be read here.

As we wrote, "This (case) represents a defining moment for privacy rights" the letter states. "We ask you to stand with consumers by telling the Supreme Court to reject the banks' appeal in Brown."

The Obama Administration soon weighed in on our side (all be it a nuanced and less than satisfactory brief) - and recommended the Court not take the case. Click here to read the article I wrote for the California Progress Report that analyzed the pro's and con's of the Administration's brief as related to the concept of pre-emption and the right to privacy in a broader sense.

As I wrote at the time, the Supreme Court could of course ignore the Administration’s recommendation and still take the case, though this is unlikely. So, for the time being, Californians right to control their personal, private financial data is secure.

And now its official! As reported by the San Francisco Chronicle, the Supreme Court has rejected the banks' appeal.

Bob Egelko - who quotes our letter in the article - writes:

Without comment, the U.S. Supreme Court denied a hearing to the American Bankers Association, which had argued that the 2004 financial privacy law conflicted with a federal law setting nationwide standards for regulating consumer credit reports. The California privacy law, the broadest of its kind in the nation, allows customers to veto a bank's attempt to share certain types of information with affiliated companies. Some of the largest banks have thousands of affiliates in fields far removed from banking.

...

The court said federal law prohibits states from limiting distribution of a bank's consumer reports - which prospective lenders, insurers and even employers can examine - but does not prevent other types of regulation. That means consumers can stop banks from sharing such information as their credit card statements, which a bank-affiliated retailer might use to target advertising based on someone's buying patterns.

Consumer rights groups argued that customers needed those protections because of a 1999 federal law that repealed a ban on bank ownership of insurance companies, brokerage houses and other financial institutions.

"These new financial supermarkets could easily create dossiers on our buying, earning, borrowing and investment histories ... and sell or share this information for purposes such as marketing or profiling," the organizations said in a letter to the Obama administration in March, urging support for the California law.

The Justice Department responded with a filing May 29 that argued that the state law conflicted with federal regulation and should have been overturned - but that the Supreme Court should decline to review it because it wasn't imposing hardships on banks. President George W. Bush's administration had asked lower courts to strike down the California law.

Click here to read the rest of the article.

Let me end with a word of caution. The Administration’s brief still gives us more than ample reason to remain concerned and vigilant. Most assuredly, we won a big victory with the Court's decision not to take this case. But as I said back in my critique of the Administration's brief, "...no “blow was struck” for the individuals fundamental, constitutional right to privacy. Or more specific to this case, no mention was even made in the Administration's brief whether they agree with another core principle we believe in: California's right to protect the private financial information of its citizens outweighs the corporation’s right to profit off it.

I suppose - if feeling exceptionally optimistic - I could conclude that perhaps the administration was signaling to the banks that if they support a national standard, they could avoid their worst nightmare of all: facing 50 different versions of data privacy rules. I've read this interpretation, though the devil would be in the details.

It goes without saying that we would support a uniform, national standard on the issue of financial privacy that mimics California's SB 1 (or something close to it). But if Obama is signaling support for a national standard that is substantially weaker than SB 1, then such a move would be no victory for privacy. Only time will tell...

Monday, June 29, 2009

Napolitano Endorses PASS ID and EFF Files Lawsuit Against the Justice Department

I'm going to keep this short and sweet today. For a detailed analysis of the recently introduced “Providing for Additional Security in States’ Identification Act” (PASS ID), check out my post from Friday.

I'm afraid to say - as I stated on Friday - even as PASS ID represents a break from, and an improvement of REAL ID, it simply isn't an acceptable alternative to those that cherish privacy and are concerned with the ever expanding power of government in areas related to "national security". The fact is, PASS ID continues the one key component of REAL ID that privacy advocates were most opposed to: the creation of a national identification card.

Unfortunately, as reported in Federal Computer Week, Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano - a former opponent of REAL ID - has endorsed PASS ID. A point I've made numerous times on this blog over the past few months, is that as Governor of Arizona, Napolitano had a decidedly mixed record on privacy. In that context, her announced support for PASS ID comes as no major surprise.

FCW reports:

Napolitano, as governor of Arizona, had a mixed record on Real ID. In June 2008, she signed legislation passed by the Arizona State Legislature to prohibit the state from complying with Real ID. However, in August 2007, Napolitano was one of the first governors to reach an agreement with the Homeland Security Department to produce an enhanced driver’s license that would also serve as a substitute for a U.S. passport at the U.S.-Mexico border.

These licenses, which are now being produced in Washington State, New York and Vermont, are designed to comply with Real ID. The National Governors Association has praised Pass ID, saying it would reduce costs, offer greater flexibility to states, eliminate the need for costly new data systems and strengthen privacy protections. However, the American Civil Liberties Union said risks to privacy are still a major concern under Pass ID.

I'll be covering the progress of this legislation right here...

Electronic Frontier Foundation Files Suit Against Justice Dept.

Where would we be without organizations like the ACLU and EFF??? Seriously! In yet another laudable effort to take on, and expose the most entrenched corporate and government powers on behalf of individual privacy, EFF has filed a lawsuit against the Justice Department demanding the public release of the surveillance guidelines that govern investigations of Americans by the FBI.

The National Journal's "Tech Daily Dose" reports:

The protocols took effect in December 2008 and detail the bureau's procedures and standards for implementing the attorney general's guidelines on approved surveillance strategies. The Electronic Frontier Foundation's complaint comes after DOJ failed to respond to a Freedom of Information Act request for a complete copy of the document. FBI General Counsel Valerie Caproni has acknowledged that "the expansion of techniques available [to the bureau] has raised privacy and civil liberties concerns."

Investigations can include the electronic collection of information from online sources and computer databases, as well as the use of grand jury subpoenas to obtain telephone and e-mail subscriber information, EFF said in a press release. Other recent policy changes allow the FBI to engage in free-ranging investigation of Internet sites, libraries, and religious institutions, the group said.

"Americans have the right to know the basic surveillance policies used by federal investigators and how their privacy is -- or is not -- being protected," EFF senior counsel David Sobel said. Read EFF's full complaint to the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia here.

As with PASS ID, I will follow this case here, and provide more details in coming posts.

Friday, June 26, 2009

PASS ID Versus REAL ID: An Inadeqaute Fix

As I always do when discussing REAL ID, before I get to the articles I want to highlight, I like to give a quick refresher course on the Act and the state revolt that it inspired:

The Real ID Act was approved by Congress - underhandedly as a rider - and then signed into law by President Bush in 2005 as part of the government's so called "war on terror".

At the time, few lawmakers even knew what they were voting for, or necessarily supported the concept to begin with. Since that time the law has evoked widespread criticism from privacy advocates and civil rights groups, which say it would create a de facto national identity card system that would be hard to manage and even harder to secure. The law requires states to issue new licenses which are supposed to screen potential terrorists and identify illegal immigrants.

Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) sums up the concerns of privacy advocates thusly:

Once the IDs and database are in place, their uses will inevitably expand to facilitate a wide range of surveillance activities. Remember, the Social Security number started innocuously enough, but it has become a prerequisite for a host of government services and been co-opted by private companies to create massive databases of personal information. A national ID poses similar dangers; for example, because "common machine-readable technology" will be required on every ID, the government and businesses will be able to easily read your private information off the cards in myriad contexts.

The States Rebel!

Since the law's enactment, at least 42 states have considered anti-Real ID legislation, and another 24 states have enacted anti-real ID bills or resolutions, and fourteen of those states have passed binding legislation prohibiting participation in the Real ID program. Five more states have already passed resolutions or statutes in 2009 - with Missouri likely becoming the next state to opt out of Real ID if its governor signs legislation currently before him.

Initially, States had until May of 2008 to implement Real ID, but the department extended that until Dec. 31, 2009. If they need more time and have met certain benchmarks, states can request an extension until May 11, 2011.

For everything that's wrong with the REAL ID Act, check out the REAL NIGHTMARE site.

The Birth of PASS ID

The Obama Administration has recently begun voicing its opposition to key components of REAL ID. This fact, combined with overwhelming state opposition, and the fast approaching deadline they face for implementation, has led to a renewed debate in the Senate as to whether it should be abolished altogether, or simply take a modified, more "mild" form, known as PASS ID?

Senator Daniel Akaka (D-HI) - seeking to reform the REAL ID Act - introduced the “Providing for Additional Security in States’ Identification Act” (PASS ID) last week with 5 co-sponsors, offering some important privacy protections, most notably, eliminating interconnected databases and repealing the requirement that states query other states or verify birth certificates with the originating agencies. The bad news is, PASS ID could ultimately become the basis for a National ID.

I would echo the comments made by the ACLU'S Chris Calabrese, Counsel of the ACLU Technology and Liberty Program:

“Senator Akaka is right in his efforts to eliminate a substantial number of the more problematic aspects of Real ID, including the creation of a national database of driver information and misuse of license information by the private sector...Any day now, we will have fully half of all states on record opposing Real ID. We agree with Secretary of Homeland Security Napolitano that the best solution to the Real ID Act is to repeal it.”

With all this said, let me get to my two featured "articles" today. Joan Friedlan, focuses on the anti-immigrant aspect of PASS ID in a piece entitled "The Real ID Act Is an Unfixable Disaster...Why Tinkering with it Won't Help". In this clip, she points out some of the disturbing similarities shared by PASS ID and REAL ID, which include:

Make non-citizens prove lawful immigration status to get a license. Immigration law is complicated, contradictory and ever-changing, so it is not surprising that REAL ID left out some categories of lawfully present immigrants who should be eligible for a license—such as trafficking—victim applicants for non-immigrant visas or those protected under the Convention against Torture.

PASS ID attempts to cure some of these deficiencies, but at the same time gives DHS unreviewable discretion to add categories of lawfully present non-citizens, leaving open the possibility that this might be done in a discriminatory or irrational way. States will likely find a shifting list of eligible immigration statuses to be confusing and cumbersome.

Recognize that exceptional circumstances – e.g. Hurricane Katrina – can make it impossible for people to provide the required documents for a license. States can set up an “exceptions process” to deal with this. But states can’t do the same for immigration status, even if people lose their documents proving immigration status in the very same disaster.

Require a passport as the only foreign document that can be used to prove identity and date of birth for a driver’s license—even though other documents such as birth certificates and school records can be used in actually obtaining legal status.

On a similar note, the ACLU has published a one page fact sheet that sums up quite nicely exactly why PASS ID is an inadequate fix for REAL ID. Here are a couple useful highlights:

PASS ID would impose the United States' first-ever national identity card system, which would violate privacy by helping to consolidate data and facilitate tracking. After a 5-year hiatus to allow for implementation, PASS ID will be required for boarding airplanes in the same manner as Real ID, and over time its use will almost certainly expand to cover other activities necessary to participate in society.

PASS ID mandates that all identity source documents be copied physically or digitally and retained as long as the license is valid. By creating troves of sensitive documents on millions of individuals, this provision will be a dream for identity thieves.

In a provision that is actually worse than Real ID, PASS ID will allow insecure technology such as radio RFID chips to be used as part of PASS ID, despite the strong potential that technology holds for tracking of individuals' movements. While PASS ID makes some concessions for the security of domestic violence victims, it still requires victims to get approval from the state before they can shield their identity.

Click here to read the fact sheet in full.

Again, I will defer to the ACLU on this, as I just couldn't agree more with the conclusion they reach on REAL ID, PASS ID, and what appears to be in the end, the government's continued efforts to march us, slowly but surely, towards a national identification card:

This legislation is entirely unnecessary because, thanks to the rebellion in the states, the Real ID Act is already dead...Rather than saving Americans from the Real ID legislation that they have rejected in such large numbers, PASS ID would actually rescue the core policies of Real ID at a time when it is about to die of its own misguided impracticality.

The problems inherent in Real ID cannot be solved by tinkering around the edges of the act. Instead, the entire unworkable system must be scrapped and replaced with a system that does not endanger Americans' privacy and civil liberties, such as a "negotiated rulemaking" process that brings together stakeholders to hash out wise and realistic improvements to driver's licenses (such a process was underway before Real ID shut it down). The PASS ID Act creates more problems than it solves, and it should not be viewed as a viable alternative to a true repeal of Real ID.

Perhaps the most important step Congress could take is to engage the American people in a real debate as to the value of a national ID. Remember, REAL ID was passed without that debate, and with fear as the trump card, and slipped deeply into a spending bill that funded the war and tsunami relief.

William Jackson of Government Computer news sums up this line of thinking nicely:

If the American people and their representatives agree that creation of some form of national ID makes sense, the government can then take steps to implement it in a way that is fair, reasonable and secure. But if we decide that people should not need papers to travel freely within the borders of their own country, the issue of creating and securing state databases of personally identifiable information becomes moot.

In the meantime, I'm afraid to say, that even as we are taking steps away from adopting the REAL ID concept as first proposed, we continue (with PASS ID anyway) moving towards something nearly as unnacceptable: a national identification card. Stay tuned...

Wednesday, June 24, 2009

More on Deep Packet Inspection: Free Speech vs. Surveillance in the Digital Age

I want to expand on my post from yesterday regarding Deep Packet Inspection (DPI) technology, Iran and China's usage of it to monitor its citizens and stifle dissent, American and European company's development and sale of this freedom crushing technology to those nations, the threat that it poses to consumer privacy (and the Internet itself) in OUR country, and how it all ties back to our own little Constitutional crisis known as warrantless wiretapping (read my post from last week on the latest revelations on that subject).

The reason I've chosen to do a follow up post on my rather extensive first stab at explaining (and understanding it myself) all of this is because, as luck would have it, Amy Goodman of Democracy Now not only wrote an op-ed that was published TODAY on this very topic, she also happened to have interviewed Josh Silver, executive director of Free Press!

Before I get to the video and Amy's article, just a reminder:

DPI technology is capable of tracking Internet communications in real time, monitoring the content, and deciding which messages or applications will get through the fastest.

Further, the Iranians appear to be using DPI "to not only block communication but to monitor it to gather information about individuals, as well as alter it for disinformation purposes." And, the Chinese government is believed to be using it to implement its "Great Firewall," "widely considered the most advanced and extensive censoring in the world" -- an "arrangement that depends on the cooperation of all the service providers."

Watch Amy Goodman's interview of Josh Silver of the Free Press, who broke this story, and recently published an in depth report on DPI technology, entitled Deep Packet Inspection: The End of the Internet as We Know It?)



I would hate to leave you all without posting a couple choice clips from Amy's OUTSTANDING op-ed, entitled Free Speech vs. Surveillance in the Digital Age:

Josh Silver, executive director of Free Press, a media policy group, says the actions of Iran and China should alert us to domestic surveillance issues in the U.S. He told me: "This technology that monitors everything that goes through the Internet is something that works, it's readily available, and there's no legislation in the United States that prevents the U.S. government from employing it...It's widely known that the major carriers, particularly AT&T and Verizon, were being asked by the NSA [National Security Agency], by the Bush administration...to deploy off-the-shelf technology made by some of these companies like Cisco." The equipment formed the backbone of the "warrantless wiretapping" program.

...

The warrantless wiretapping program was widely considered illegal. After abruptly switching his position in midcampaign, then-Sen. Barack Obama voted along with most in Congress to grant telecom companies like AT&T and Verizon retroactive immunity from prosecution. The New York Times recently reported that the NSA maintains a database called Pinwale, with millions of intercepted e-mail, including some from former President Bill Clinton.

...

Dissenters in Iran and China persist despite repression that is enabled in part by equipment from U.S. and European companies. In the U.S., the Obama administration is following a dangerous path with Bush-era spy programs that should be suspended and prosecuted, not extended and defended.

I would point everyone again to my post last week about the latest warrantless wiretapping revelations, which includes video of Senator Feingold's interrogation of AG Eric Holder, as well as Keith Olbermann's interview of New York Times reporter James Risen. Also of note, is the article I cite by the always brilliant and informative constitutional law expert, Glenn Greenwald.

Click here to read the rest of Amy Goodman's piece from today.

Tuesday, June 23, 2009

Iran, China, and Deep Packet Inspection: A Cautionary Tale

Recently, electronics manufacturers have developed so-called Deep Packet Inspection (DPI) technology capable of tracking Internet communications in real time, monitoring the content, and deciding which messages or applications will get through the fastest.

Here’s how it works, as explained by The Free Press in their recent report Deep Packet Inspection: The End of the Internet as We Know It?:

"Messages on the Internet are broken down into small units called packets. Each packet contains a header and a data field. The header contains processing information, including the source and destination addresses. The data field contains everything else, including the identity of the source application (such as a Web browser request, a peer-to-peer transfer, or an e-mail), as well as the message itself (part of the contents of a Web page, file or e-mail). Packets are much like letters – the outside of the envelope is like the packet header, and the inside, like the data field, carries the message.

...

"DPI technology opens and reads the data field in real time, allowing network operators to identify and control, at a precise level, everyday uses of the Internet. Operators can tag packets for fast-lane or slowlane treatment – or block the packets altogether – based on what they contain or which application sent them."

...

"Although early uses of real-time DPI by ISPs have been geared toward targeted advertising and reducing congestion, manufacturers market the technology for its ability to determine and control every use of a subscriber’s Internet connection. When a network provider chooses to install DPI equipment, that provider knowingly arms itself with the capacity to monitor and monetize the Internet in ways that threaten to destroy Net Neutrality and the essential open nature of the Internet."

But here's where it starts to get a little freaky. Yesterday, the Wall Street Journal reported that Iran and China are likely using DPI technology to monitor and control the Internet. The Iranians appear to be using DPI "to not only block communication but to monitor it to gather information about individuals, as well as alter it for disinformation purposes."

The Chinese government is believed to be using it to implement its "Great Firewall," "widely considered the most advanced and extensive censoring in the world" -- an "arrangement that depends on the cooperation of all the service providers."

The Wall Street Journal writes:

The Iranian regime has developed, with the assistance of European telecommunications companies, one of the world's most sophisticated mechanisms for controlling and censoring the Internet, allowing it to examine the content of individual online communications on a massive scale...The monitoring capability was provided, at least in part, by a joint venture of Siemens AG, the German conglomerate, and Nokia Corp., the Finnish cellphone company, in the second half of 2008, Ben Roome, a spokesman for the joint venture, confirmed.

...

All eyes have been on the Internet amid the crisis in Iran, and government attempts to crack down on information. The infiltration of Iranian online traffic could explain why the government has allowed the Internet to continue to function -- and also why it has been running at such slow speeds in the days since the results of the presidential vote spurred unrest.

Users in the country report the Internet having slowed to less than a tenth of normal speeds. Deep packet inspection delays the transmission of online data unless it is offset by a huge increase in processing power, according to Internet experts.

...

Countries with repressive governments aren't the only ones interested in such technology. Britain has a list of blocked sites, and the German government is considering similar measures. In the U.S., the National Security Agency has such capability, which was employed as part of the Bush administration's "Terrorist Surveillance Program." A White House official wouldn't comment on if or how this is being used under the Obama administration.

...

Several years ago, research by OpenNet discovered the government using filtering equipment from a U.S. company, Secure Computing Corp. Due to the U.S. trade embargo on Iran, in place since the 1979 Islamic revolution overthrew the U.S.-backed shah, that was illegal. Secure Computing, now owned by McAfee Inc., at the time denied any knowledge of the use of its products in Iran. McAfee said due diligence before the acquisition revealed no contract or support being provided in Iran.

Click here to read the rest of the Wall Street Journal's article.

The dangers that DPI technology poses to consumer privacy cannot - and should not - be understated. It would give network providers unprecedented access to Internet users private web surfing habits as well as enormous power over consumers and the evolution of the net itself.

US companies Comcast and Cox have already sparked widespread concern about abuses of online privacy through their own controversial use of the technology. It was just recently that NebuAd offered an advertising service to network providers that would secretly sit at key places within the network and monitor all consumer communications passing through the network, using DPI to search within packets for URLs and search terms. The devices would then analyze some or all of that traffic to identify consumer behavior patterns.

NebuAd artificially inserted packets of data into the stream of traffic to redirect Web browsers to a NebuAd-owned domain for the purpose of placing unsolicited tracking cookies on the user’s computer. In March 2008, Internet users began detecting unsolicited cookies originating from NebuAd systems put in place by ISPs without notice.

The good news is NebuAd is virtually gone, and thanks to an organized and effective effort by public interest groups in 2008, so to is the use of DPI technology for such purposes...for the time being. But the fact is, the manufacturers of DPI equipment are still in business (thanks partly to Iran and China), and still looking for ways to put their monitoring and discrimination tools to use here in America.

And this leads me back to the much more sinister uses of this technology being utilized by Iran and China. If ISP's in America are allowed to take advantage of DPI, how different would this really be than allowing our government to do so too?

It was OUR government that orchestrated a massive, illegal warrantless wiretapping program targeting American citizens. It was also our government that then gave retroactive immunity to those telecommunication companies that ILLEGALLY shared our private information with it...a classic government-corporate win-win deal to be sure.

In light of that tidbit of trivia, why should we believe - even for a second - that such a scenario could not occur again? Our government may someday want to monitor our movements and actions on the net. But in this case, ISP's are the gatekeepers, and it is they that can and are monitoring every "movement" we make on the net thanks to DPI technology. The government asks "can we have that please", the ISP's say "of course". Suddenly, America isn't so different from Iran and China after all...but not in a kumbaya sort of way.

Josh Silver, executive director of Free Press, connected these critically important dots in a press release yesterday:

"DPI technology is America's sleeping giant. It has been widely deployed by Internet service providers across the country, and could be secretly put to use without our knowledge or consent.

"The American Internet experience is not the same as that of Iran or China. But we see how dangerous this technology can be when it falls into the wrong hands, or is used for the wrong purposes. Whether DPI is wielded by a government or a big corporation, the power to pursue political or economic discrimination is disturbing."


...

"We urge our lawmakers to heed the cautionary tale of Iran and China. We should not blindly permit concentrated control over the Internet. Before this technology is widely activated, we encourage Congress to open a broad inquiry to determine what is in the best interest of the American people."


In a speech just last month, President Barack Obama did give us some reason to be optimistic, stating:

"Our pursuit of cybersecurity will not -- I repeat, will not include -- monitoring private sector networks or Internet traffic. We will preserve and protect the personal privacy and civil liberties that we cherish as Americans. Indeed, I remain firmly committed to Net Neutrality so we can keep the Internet as it should be -- open and free."

But I have a long memory, and I won't soon forget how fast and thorough the President flip flopped on telecom immunity. So, let me finish by quoting the Free Press one last time from their seminal report, Deep Packet Inspection: The End of the Internet as We Know It?:

The debate over the use of DPI has only begun. Appropriate uses of DPI technologies do exist. But the applications we have seen thus far are not encouraging, and the burden of proof for their benefit rests squarely with the network operator.

It appears I have yet another important issue to cover here.

Monday, June 22, 2009

The Emerging Battle over Behavioral Targeting

I'm going to defer on this issue today to Jeffrey Chester, executive director of the Center for Digital Democracy (CDD). CDD has been at the forefront of exposing all kinds of invasive online and mobile marketing practices as well as offering concrete regulatory measures that would more adequately protect consumer privacy. A few days back Chester testified before Congress urging it to pass legislation that would ensure meaningful consumer protection online, especially for privacy.

This from CDD's press release on his testimony: As more consumers increasingly rely on the Internet to obtain such sensitive services as financial products or health information...it is especially critical that the public be assured they will be treated fairly when engaged in online commerce.

Chester pointed to the failure of the regulatory system that should have protected Americans from irresponsible business practices that led to the current financial crisis. “As with our financial system, privacy and consumer protection regulators have failed to keep abreast of developments in the area they are supposed to oversee,” he explained. “In order to ensure adequate trust in online marketing—an important and growing sector of our economy—Congress must enact sensible policies to protect consumers.”

“Whether using a search engine, watching an online video, creating content on a social network, receiving an email, or playing an interactive video game, we are being digitally shadowed online,” Chester told a joint hearing by the House Subcommittee on Commerce, Trade, and Consumer Protection, and the Subcommittee on Communications, Technology, and the Internet.

“Our travels through the digital media are being monitored, and digital dossiers on us are being created—and even bought and sold.” Singling out behavioral and “predictive” targeting for their violations of user privacy, Chester noted that the “consumer profiling and targeted advertising take place largely without our knowledge or consent, and affects such sensitive areas as financial transactions and health-related inquiries. Children and youth, among the most active users of the Internet and mobile devices, are especially at risk in this new media-marketing ecosystem.”

Chester’s CDD, in collaboration with the U.S. Public Interest Research Group (USPIRG), was instrumental in bringing the online privacy issue to the forefront in a series of petitions filed with the Federal Trade Commission in 2006 and 2007. Earlier this year, the two groups called on the agency to “conduct a special investigation into mobile marketing privacy threats and inappropriate practices targeting children, adolescents, and multicultural consumers.”

...Chester called on Congress to enact meaningful regulations to protect consumer privacy in the online and mobile arenas, effectively bringing the FTC’s Fair Information Practice Principles fully into the digital age.

“Americans shouldn’t have to trade away their privacy and accept online profiling and tracking as the price they must pay in order to access the Internet and other digital media,” Chester declared, adding that far from being an impediment to continued growth in the online sector, meaningful privacy safeguards will actually stimulate the digital economy.

“The uncertainty over the loss of privacy and other consumer harms will continue to undermine confidence in the online advertising business,” he explained. “That’s why the online ad industry will actually greatly benefit from privacy regulation. Given a new regulatory regime protecting privacy, industry leaders and entrepreneurs will develop new forms of marketing services where data collection and profiling are done in an above-board, consumer-friendly fashion.”

With that, let me direct you to an article on these hearings in DMnews.com which details some of the industry's counter arguments to those by Chester, and their expected heavy lobbying of Congress against meaningful regulation (i.e. "self regulation" or "voluntary regulation"):

Yahoo argued that a consumer's privacy should be respected and that online advertisers should be transparent about practices in order to build trust. The company recently announced its new data retention policy, in which Yahoo will retain the vast majority of its Web log data in identifiable form for only 90 days.

...

The Direct Marketing Association, for its part, is working with the American Association of Advertising Agencies, the Association of National Advertisers, the Interactive Advertising Bureau and the Better Business Bureau on self-regulation guidelines.“We hope to be out with [those guidelines] soon. We're moving along, responding to the Federal Trade Commission," said Jerry Cerasale, SVP of government affairs for the DMA and a hearing attendee. "This is an area where we think self-regulation can work. With technology changing rapidly all the time, we think self-regulation gives us the ability to change fairly quickly and make adjustments.”

...

Interestingly, Google is reportedly in favor of federal legislation, probably due to the challenges that legislation on a local level would create. Christine Chen, a Google spokeswoman, expects legislation later this year. “Congress is certainly interested in introducing some sort of privacy legislation later this year,” Chen said. “It is really unclear to us what kind it will be. Whether it will be a broad based effort [covering consumer privacy] or whether it will be specifically related to behavioral targeting, we honestly don't know what they are going to do.” Chen said behavioral targeting is still an area of growth and opportunity. In the absence of legislation, Google introduced its own behavioral product in beta in March. Called Ad Preferences Manager, it enables the user to pick which interest-based ads they want to receive or opt out of them altogether.

...

When this issue first surfaced in November 2007, privacy groups petitioned the FTC to take action. Now, Congress is involved. Last April, House members first met to discuss the possibility of introducing federal privacy legislation. One of the ideas that has been discussed is an opt-in strategy in which consumers could elect to allow their behavior to be tracked.

...

Despite the continued controversy around behavioral targeting, vendors don't appear to be shying away from it. At the recent Internet Retailer Conference and Exhibition in Boston, a couple of exhibitors were showcasing new solutions with a behavioral targeting tie-in.

...

Home fitness online retailer Smooth Fitness saw a nearly 20% increase in average order value using behavioral targeting, according to Amadesa. The behavioral targeting Amadesa is engaged in is based around one specific Web site, as opposed to what happens with most advertising networks, which produce cookies that follow a user from site to site.

I'll get into this issue a lot deeper in future posts. Click here to read more.