Monday, December 3, 2007

Editorial: Facebook move doesn't clear up privacy fears

During my 5 days absence a lot has happened in regards to the MoveOn versus Facebook clash. Unless you've been living under a rock, I'm sure you heard the people won this round.

As MoveOn noted in a November 30th action alert, Facebook's "about face" is something we should all celebrate:

Big news! Last night, Facebook changed their policy and announced that no private purchases made on other websites would be displayed publicly on Facebook "without users proactively consenting." This is a huge victory for online privacy—and shows how regular people can band together to make a difference as the rules of the Internet get written.

...

The Washington Post, New York Times, and media outlets around the world cited the 50,000 Internet users who joined MoveOn's Facebook group and online petition as critical in getting Facebook to reconsider their policy. The New York Times called it a "mass protest" and London's Telegraph newspaper said we achieved "dramatic change."

But, before we pop the champaigne and declare the 29th of November to be "National Privacy Protection Day", check out this editorial by the San Jose Mercury News entitled "Facebook move doesn't clear up privacy fears".

As the editorial points out, this is only one part of a much larger struggle to protect ones personal information - particularly in cyberspace:

The backlash against Facebook last week is a lesson to all Internet companies: Tread more carefully with consumer privacy, even in this linked-in age.

...

But the issue of privacy in the Internet age doesn't stop there. Facebook fixed the notification feature, but it's still collecting the data. Web sites like Facebook and MySpace make it possible to share intimate details of our lives with online friends and contacts. That allows the sites themselves to collect troves of personal data, such as what movie we saw, what books we like and where we plan to go on vacation. And they can share that data with Internet marketers.

...

Despite Facebook's concession, the Center for Digital Democracy and other privacy groups plan to press the Federal Trade Commission to examine Internet marketing practices. It's time to look at updating the ground rules for marketing in the Internet age. Social networking sites have brought us into a new era of connectedness. But the basic expectation of privacy must not change.

Click here for the complete editorial...

Tuesday, November 27, 2007

More on Facebook Violations of Privacy

See the post below for the full story (earlier today), but I had to add these new revelations supplied by MoveOn.org as to how, specifically, member privacy is being violated by Facebook:

"Like our work together for Net Neutrality, this is fundamentally about the future of the Internet as a public space.

Here's what some people wrote on the public Wall of our Facebook group:

"I made a purchase yesterday for my wife for Christmas...When my wife logged onto Facebook, there was an entry in her news feed that I had bought a ring from Overstock. It had a link to the ring and everything. Christmas ruined."

—Sean L. from Massachusetts

"I saw my girlfriend bought an item i had been saying i wanted...so now part of my christmas gift has been ruined. Facebook is ruining christmas!"

—Matthew H. from New York

"Facebook, are you kidding me? This is way out of bounds for a program I never opted into."

—Matthew F. from Georgia3

For these reasons, I will include the rest of MoveOn's request for action:

Dear MoveOn member,

When you buy a book, movie, or gift online, do you want that information automatically shared with everyone you know?

Last week, the social networking site Facebook began doing just that. Private purchases made by Facebook users on other sites were posted on Facebook for people's co-workers, friends, and random acquaintances to see.1 Why? To benefit corporate advertisers.

Other sites are looking at Facebook's example to see if they can get away with similar privacy breaches. We need to draw a line in the sand—making clear that the wish lists of corporate advertisers must not come before the basic privacy rights of Internet users.

Can you urge Facebook to stop violating privacy rights? If you're on Facebook, join our Facebook group and invite your Facebook friends. If you're not on Facebook, you can sign our petition to Facebook.

You can join the Facebook group "Facebook, stop invading my privacy!" here:

http://www.moveon.org/r?r=3202&id=11708-1187820-11hUe8&t=5

Click here to sign the petition (see box at right for petition text):

http://civ.moveon.org/facebookprivacy/?rc=fb_air&id=11708-1187820-11hUe8&t=6

Facebook, Privacy, and MoveON

Note: I will be in DC until next Monday...then back to posting here...

Before I leave however, I suppose its encumbent on me to post something about Facebook - the hot new "online community" site - and the virtual rash of privacy violations currently being associated with it.

Let's first start with the company's deal with advertisers. This from The Independent:

The new technology will also allow businesses to build custom-designed "pages" on the social networking site. Users can become "fans" of a company's page, which means any interaction with that brand will be broadcast to their Facebook friends.

Privacy campaigners are up in arms about Facebook's move, lambasting the company for selling out its users to the highest bidders - companies such as Coca-Cola, Sony, Verizon and Blockbuster.

Jeff Chester, executive director of the Centre for Digital Democracy in Washington, warned yesterday that Facebook has mounted a "massive invasion of user privacy". He added: "The authorities need to crack down on Facebook and MySpace to stop data collection and make sure people's privacy is respected." He wants regulators, including the European Commission's Privacy Authority, to investigate.

Deborah Pierce, who heads the lobby group Privacy Activism, said: "Users should be concerned. They have no idea who has access to information about them from the site."

In the US, legal experts, such as the University of Minnesota law professor William McGeveran, have queried whether Facebook's ad strategy is even legal. He believes that under a 100-year-old New York privacy law users may be able to sue for damages if their photos are used for advertising purposes without their consent.

But that's not all. Now MoveOn.org, the liberal civic and political action group, is sounding the privacy invasion alarms in a campaign against Facebook, demanding they respect the privacy of its users.

CNet details the clash:

Last week, a feud began to brew between leftist activist group MoveOn.org and social-networking site Facebook concerning its "Beacon" advertisements, which broadcast information about users' activity on third-party partner sites to their friends' Facebook newsfeeds. According to MoveOn, it's a violation of user privacy because there's no way to universally opt out of Beacon ads. Facebook retorted, and the argument has turned into a legitimate debate over how far is really too far when it comes to sharing information about members' activity.

...

"Facebook should explain why they chose at the last minute to put the wish lists of corporate advertisers ahead of the privacy interests of their users," MoveOn spokesman Adam Green said in a statement from the organization. "Facebook has the potential to revolutionize how we communicate with each other and organize around issues together in a 21st century democracy. But to succeed, they need the trust of their users. The fact that Facebook proactively chose to make it harder for their users to keep private information from being made public will rub a lot of Facebook users the wrong way. The ultimate act of good faith would be to switch to an opt-in policy."

The magazine Techworld has more on the specific areas of disagreement:

MoveOn's disdain is aimed mainly at Facebook's new advertising program, known as "Beacon," which automatically posts information to a user's Facebook profile about their online purchases and other activities.

Facebook gives users the choice of opting out of the Beacon program through its privacy policy, but MoveOn believes the nature of the ad program demands a tougher policy, one that requires that users opt in before having their information tracked and posted in the program.


...

Facebook's Beacon program funnels information about a user's Web activities back to their profiles, where it can be viewed by their network of friends. For instance, if a user buys something on an e-commerce site, a note describing what and where was purchased is added to the user's profile. Or if a user posts a review of a restaurant or hotel on some sites, that information can also be pulled into the profile.

...

"The obvious solution is to switch to an 'opt in' policy, like most other applications on Facebook," MoveOn wrote on its Facebook page.

MoveOn is not the only entity that has raised concerns about the new program. Earlier this month, The New York Times reported that the social ads may violate New York state law. In addition, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has been pressured by privacy groups and others to create a do-not-track list that would enable Web users to opt out of a range of marketing-focused tracking programs at once.

For more of the article click here. In my opinion the answer is simple: In today's world in which ones most personal information can be shared around the world in seconds, "OPT-IN" is always the superior option than "opt-out". Period!

Monday, November 26, 2007

Cellphone Tracking Powers on Request

My apologies for the long absence, I've been battling the cold of the century!

Now, back to the world of Big Brother!

This story immediately caught my eye...sending chills down my spine in the process. I first heard of cell phone tracking a few tears back...in fact, it wasn't just tracking, it was the government actually listening in on people through THEIR cell phones. Granted, the people they were doing it to were mobsters, but it doesn't take a brain surgeon to realize this "ability" to not only track but listen in on people, by the government, through our cell phones, is something that could be grossly abused.

Apparently, the government has been tracking cell phone users...A LOT...and without probable cause!

This from the Washington Post:

Federal officials are routinely asking courts to order cellphone companies to furnish real-time tracking data so they can pinpoint the whereabouts of drug traffickers, fugitives and other criminal suspects, according to judges and industry lawyers.

In some cases, judges have granted the requests without requiring the government to demonstrate that there is probable cause to believe that a crime is taking place or that the inquiry will yield evidence of a crime. Privacy advocates fear such a practice may expose average Americans to a new level of government scrutiny of their daily lives.

...

"Most people don't realize it, but they're carrying a tracking device in their pocket," said Kevin Bankston of the privacy advocacy group Electronic Frontier Foundation. "Cellphones can reveal very precise information about your location, and yet legal protections are very much up in the air."

...

"Permitting surreptitious conversion of a cellphone into a tracking device without probable cause raises serious Fourth Amendment concerns especially when the phone is in a house or other place where privacy is reasonably expected," said Judge Stephen William Smith of the Southern District of Texas, whose 2005 opinion on the matter was among the first published.

...

The trend's secrecy is troubling, privacy advocates said. No government body tracks the number of cellphone location orders sought or obtained. Congressional oversight in this area is lacking, they said. And precise location data will be easier to get if the Federal Communication Commission adopts a Justice Department proposal to make the most detailed GPS data available automatically.

Click here to read the article in its entirety...

Friday, November 16, 2007

Panel Drops Immunity From Eavesdropping Bill

Well here's a bit of good news. The Senate Judiciary Committee dropped language giving telecom companies immunity from a bill to overhaul the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act. But, we should be clear, that issue has not nearly been resolved...the buck has simply been passed. However, just a week ago it was looking pretty likely that such immunity was going to be included...so I think its worth mentioning here.

Similarly, last night "the House voted 227 to 189, generally along party lines, to approve its own version of the FISA bill, which also does not include immunity."

More from the New York Times:

By a 10 to 9 vote, the committee...dropped a key provision for immunity for telecommunications companies that another committee had already approved. The Senate leadership will have to decide how to deal with the immunity question on the Senate floor.

...

But the administration has made clear that President Bush will veto any bill that does not include what it considers necessary tools for government eavesdropping, including the retroactive immunity for phone carriers...

It should also be noted that Senator Russ Feingold proposed an amendment that would have deleted the liability shield, and therefore banned any telecom immunity, but it failed by a 12-7 vote (with Democrats Feinstein and Whitehouse siding with all the Republicans). Feingold said through a spokesman that he plans to offer his amendment again when the bill goes to the Senate floor.

And Sen. Christopher Dodd has vowed to prevent the bill from going to a vote, as long as it cloaks corporations with legal protections.

So this fight is far from over. For the full article click here.

Study: Half of retailers' wireless data easy to Hack

This study really highlights why it was such a disappointment to privacy protection advocates that the Governor bowed to money and pressure from the retail industry and vetoed
Assemblyman Dave Jones data security bill, AB 779 last month.

These new findings, in addition to the fact that the bill sailed through the legislature this year with near unanimous support (which is almost unheard of!), signifies this issue if far from dead...and AB 779, or a version of it, will be back in 2008.

The Washington Post reports:

"AirDefense Inc., an Atlanta-based maker of security products for wireless data systems, found about 25 percent of the stores' 4,748 wireless access points were exchanging data with no encryption at all to foil electronic eavesdroppers. Another 25 percent were using an outdated encryption method called Wireless Equivalent Privacy that is easily cracked by thieves using widely available tools."

...

"You can drive down a street with a laptop and easily find wireless access points, and it does not require a great degree of sophistication," said Avivah Litan, a security analyst with Gartner Inc. "In technical circles, people talk about this all the time, but nobody ever puts it together broadly like this survey."

...

TJX said in March that at least 45.7 million cards were exposed, although recent court filings by banks suing TJX estimate than 100 million were. Canadian investigators concluded in September that TJX had failed to upgrade its encryption from the older WEP method by the time the eavesdropping began in July 2005.

...

AirDefense privately notified retailers when it found major security flaws, Rushing said. It is not disclosing the names of individual retailers to avoid drawing hackers' attention. Representatives for the National Retail Federation and credit card associations Visa and MasterCard declined comment.

Read the full Washington Post article here - and don't be surprised when this study re-emerges next year as more proof positive that Californians deserve increased protections of their private personal data - and greater accountability for those that are responsible for it being compromised.

Thursday, November 15, 2007

Redefine Privacy...Umm...No Thanks

I just couldn't let this one lie (see last post for more)...so I'm including one more write up on this week's mind blowing suggestion by Donald Kerr - the principal deputy director of national intelligence in testimony before the Senate Intelligence Committee - that we as a nation should "redefine" the meaning of privacy (to let's just say something far less "private").

My initial response to the latest example of a Bush administration official saying something so ludicrous and scary that it forces us to take multiple "double takes" was: "But if our current privacy protection rights are being so thoroughly eviscerated and stomped on, why would I want to weaken them?"

I thought this article in The Progressive Daily Beacon sums up well why all Americans should take to the streets if this new "definition" is EVER adopted:

Why exactly does the government need to listen to an absent father's phone call to his daughter on her birthday? Under what possible circumstance is it vital that the CEO of RJ Reynolds be made privy to a mother's email sent to her son away at university? Mister Kerr's concept grows creepier by the moment. His understanding of privacy is really quite perverted.

...

The point Mister Kerr needs to understand is that there has never been, in all of human history, a government or business that was capable of protecting, honoring and respecting the sanctity of any individuals privacy. And, frankly, nothing about the current government or today's corporate leadership inspires confidence that anything in that area has changed over time. So, in closing, we've considered Mister Kerr's kind suggestion that we redefine our understanding of privacy and we've decided not to invite him, the government and business into our very personal lives.

I realize the Orwell analogy can seem like its being over used when describing the current government and corporate assault on the principles of privacy and liberty, but its hard to find a better fit. From RFID's to "enhanced drivers licenses" to REAL ID to wiretapping to surveillance, we truly are entering a "Brave New World" of Big Brother at every street corner, running through every phone and Internet line, and always tracking, always listening.

For the rest of the article click here...and if you want to find out a whole lot more on multitude of attacks on our privacy, all being driven what I call the "Big Three" - Fear, Money, and Power (I'll discuss these more in future posts) - please check out the sites of some of the groups we have linked on the sidebar of this blog.